Farage did not attend Wednesday’s Budget seat because he claimed someone had moved his seat reservation. He did find time however to hold yet another press conference afterwards.
He still backs Truss’s 2022 Budget although 4 years on he has discovered that she should also have cut public spending
Asked whether he preferred Healey’s budget or the disastrous one given under Liz Truss in 2022, which he previously praised but led to Truss’s demise as prime minister, Farage said he had liked the top lines of the Truss budget but “what I hadn’t understood was they didn’t cut spending”.
Labour’s first Chancellor was Philip Snowden and he presented Labour’s first ever Budget in 1924.
Snowden was a member of the Independent Labour Party and a socialist but economically he was a Gladstonian Liberal. He believed that significant change would only come with a socialist society. Hence in his Budget he stuck to Treasury rules which did not involve intervening to address unemployment. However he was keen to stress the Government’s working class credentials. He focused on what was known as the ‘free breakfast’ That is breakfast items free of tariffs. These included, tea, sugar, cocoa, chicory and prunes.
In his 2026 Budget John Healey echoed Snowden. Clearly he does not think change will come in a socialist society. However he did follow the Snowden line of not doing anything too dramatic. Snowden would not have taxed Bank profits though. Healey did however remove tariffs on a range of goods available in supermarkets.
Whether the list is specifically focused on working class voters I’m not entirely sure. Gherkins has attracted Badenoch’s ridicule. As a former McDonalds employee she has clearly forgotten that they are part of a burger. Jam and marmalade makes more sense. These are big sellers (on toast) in Wetherspoons breakfasts. £2.65 two toast, jam/marmalade, tea/coffee
It might be thought that the Telegraph would have some sympathy for Liz Truss. However following no stars review of her new book Bank Job, Matt the Telegraph’s cartoonist has weighed in.
The FT (Alphaville) while also critical of the book notes that Truss does touch on areas- the bond markets and the need for democratic control by elected politicians of the economy- that should also resonate on the left. Not of course that the left wants Truss’s economics
Below is an extract from a Westminster Hall debate held on 27th October on the importance of cask ale. Carlsberg’s decision to close their Burton brewery was touched on with a demand that the relevant Minister call in the CEO. There is a link to the full debate below
Stephanie Peacock, Under Secretary for Digital, Media, Culture & Sport
My hon. Friend rightly mentioned the proposed closure of Marston’s brewery in Burton upon Trent, which I know he raised directly with the Prime Minister during Prime Minister’s questions. Carlsberg Britvic’s proposal is a blow to the workforce, the local community and the identity of Burton upon Trent and the surrounding area. Brewing is part of the fabric the area, and with more than 300 potential job losses and workers facing uncertainty, the Government stand ready to support them through Jobcentre Plus and the rapid response service. We will ensure that tailored support is available to help people to find new opportunities and to protect their livelihoods. The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs will remain in close contact with Carlsberg Britvic throughout the consultation process.
I welcome the work that the Government are doing, but has the Secretary of State dragged in the chief executive of Carlsberg? This seems to be a pattern of behaviour, happening not just in Burton, but in Wolverhampton as well. It seems intent on closing down all its cask ale breweries.
I was about to answer the right hon. Member’s question. Of course, that would be for the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, and I will speak to Ministers directly following this debate. While this debate is not on that particular issue, I absolutely recognise that it is integral to the right hon. Member’s area and the surrounding area. I will speak to DEFRA Ministers directly.
The significance of this Times Editorial (28th October) should not be missed.
Times Editorials quite frequently reference Farage and Reform along the lines of, it could be an alternative if need be. Think for example about right-wing media in France views Le Pen. It’s clear however that Farage is no longer regarded as a serious contender. That of course is not the be all an end all but it marks an important moment. Calling out Reform’s racism is essential work.
As Fleetwood beat Arsenal Eric Hobsbawm on Football Cup competitions & class
The Marxist historian Eric Hobsbawm wrote about the link between a working class identity and culture and the rise of professional football. Hobsbawm himself was certainly a football fan and was suspected of being an Arsenal fan. Unfortunately despite the author of an impressive new intellectual biography of Hobsbawm, Emile Chabal being an Arsenal fan this still not been confirmed.
In the Invention of Tradition (jointly with Terence Ranger) Hobsbawm argued that the history of football cup finals tells the historian more about the development of an urban working class culture than more conventional sources.
In the Making of the Working Class 1870-1914 (a nod and a critique of E P Thompson as Hobsbawm notes) he argues that an increasing secular tendency saw working class support for unions and the Labour Party but it was also characterised by fish and chip shops and cup finals.
On 27th October 2026 Fleetwood in Fylde beat Arsenal in the Football League Cup on penalties. A significant proportion of the inhabitants of Fleetwood were there, famous for the production of Fisherman’s Friends. There were also (Sky) 933 Arsenal fans.
A reminder that football is about more than big money and superstar players. On the night football can beat both. What Hobsbawm would made of the result as an historian may have differed from his perspective as a fan…
The FT Editorial on Lula’s victory (26th October) says that the bond markets are ‘unnerved’. No news yet on whether Lula has received a solidarity telegram from Liz Truss. It does however concede that Lula does not have to appoint a banker as Finance Minister.
Meanwhile at the Times (Editorial 26th October) there is concern that Bolsonaro Jnr was not the right candidate to defeat Lula but a conclusion of a storm warning. Whether the storm relates to the bond markets or a potential Trump influenced coup is left unsaid.
Lula has of course the power of the millions who voted for him to push through change. On this occasion he may have little choice but to rely on it
Meanwhile Liz Truss has launched a parallel narrative in her new book which is officially called Bank Job. You can read the introduction free and its fair to say that Truss is expanding further on her theory that the world consists of a conspiracy against her.
Truss would be entertaining on Celebrity Traitors because she would have concluded from day one that everyone in the castle was a Traitor while she was the only Faithful. Strangely in 2024 when Celebrity Traitors was only a possibility the production company named Truss as someone they’d like to get on the show.
Anyway in the book she does name some Traitors including Michael Gove (fair enough it must be said) and Mel Stride. However pretty much anyone who was a Tory Minister while Truss was in the Cabinet and for 49 days PM fits the requirements.
I’ll post more about the book when I can summon up the intellectual energy
Markets of course don’t have a physical existence, this is about those who essentially bet on the future of market capitalism. The impact on ordinary people who do the work that keeps it going is not a consideration here.