Their Lords of Misrule & Ours
Lords of Misrule (occasionally also women, but research here is sparse) are a feature of various moments of the traditional calendar and certainly the twelve days of Christmas from 26th December.
Much historiography focuses on the Lord of Misrule as a figure ‘elected’ in Royal Household and the Inns of Court as a sort of ‘world turned upside down’ figure who subverts traditional authority. At this level the Lord of Misrule is largely a figure of mockery and fun, a way of releasing tensions within authority structures.
William Hone in his Sports and Pastimes of the English People (1833) quotes Stow ‘At the feast of Christmas in the King’s Court there was appointed a Lord of Misrule, or master of merry disports. The same merry fellow made his appearance at the house of every nobleman and person of distinction.’.
The ‘taking the piss’ out of authority was real enough but it was with licence.
The tradition however was not confined to the upper reaches of society but was also found amongst the lower orders. Philippe Stubbs cover this in his Anatomie of Abuses (1583). In this extract he complains that Lords of Misrule disrupted Church services and this was certainly not approved of:
Thus al things fet in order, then haue they their Hobby-
horfes, 6 dragons & other Antiques, togither with their baudie Pipers
and thundering Drummers to ftrike 7 vp the deuils daunce withall.
then, marc he thefe 8 heathen company towards the Church 9 and
Church-yard, their pipers pipeing, their drummers thundring, their
flumps dauwcing, their bels iyngling, their handkerchefs fwinging 10
about their heds like madmen, their hobbie horfes and other monitors
fkirmiming amongft the route 11 : & in this forte they go to the
Church 12 (I fay) & into the Church, 12 (though the Minifter be at praier
or preaching), dancing & fwinging [t]heir ha/zdkercheifs 13 ouer their
heds in the Church, like deuils incarnate, with fuch a corcfufe 14 noife,
Natalie Zemon Davis in her 1971 article (Past and Present 50) ‘The Reasons of Misrule: Youth Groups and Charivaris in Sixteenth-Century France’, argues that in France the numerous Lords of Misrule in the sixteenth century were very largely comprised of unmarried young men. Their mockery of authority was, she argues, primarily a way of providing a socialisation process where those involved went on in later years to become the figures of authority they had earlier mocked.
Of course sometimes the mockery got out of hand in a way that was much rarer in Royal Households and the Inns of Courts.
Perhaps the difference between their Lords of Misrule and ours was that the latter could move from playing a role in social control towards subverting it.











