Once Again on the Day-Night Test: a perpetual Ashes looms?
The day-night Test between England and the West Indies at Edgbaston which ended with an England victory on Saturday night after less than three of the scheduled five days proved to be a fascinating affair though not predominantly because it was the first UK day-night Test.
There was comment that the pink ball was hard to see as darkness fell and that it performed a little differently to the red ball for bowlers. It didn’t seem to make a great deal of difference for batsmen, certainly not if Alastair Cook’s 243 was anything to go by.
It was clear that not all the audience stayed until the end of the evenings play which was scheduled, weather permitting, to be 9.30pm or later depending on over rate. It is not exactly warm sitting more or less stationary outside on an August evening and comment suggested that the infrastructure around the Test, last train times for example, had not taken account of the finish times. Hence people were leaving well before the end of the final session on the first day. It rained on the second evening and the third saw an England victory.
The issue that caused most comment however was not the playing times but that the match contained none of the ebb and flow of the best cricket games, the current West Indies side being a shadow of their great predecessors.
It remains to be seen if they can rally for the other two Tests but there was talk of pursuing the idea of a two-league international Test structure with promotion and demotion. You could argue that this gives Tests more of a coherent structure than the current more or less stand-alone series, the Ashes notwithstanding.
That of course is what is behind the idea. Namely to play the Ashes more frequently, not least because it attracts crowds and profits.
Some might say that part of the attraction of the Ashes is that they were played for over sustained intervals of time and others might also note that they were played exclusively during the day.
The times they are a changin’. The issues are whether it’s for the better and in whose interests.



Leave a Reply