Articles

The 2018 Good (cask) Beer Guide: hats off to Roger Protz

In Uncategorized on September 14, 2017 by kmflett

The 2018 Good (cask) Beer Guide: Hats Off to Roger Protz

The 2018 Good Beer Guide, the 45th, is Roger Protz’s last as Editor and this time I don’t think there was a ‘special meeting’ of the Editorial Board to get rid of him. Rather he is 78 and far from retiring he has lots of other projects he needs to get on with.

The Guide is a tribute to CAMRA volunteers and the work of Protz in keeping the Guide relevant.

If you want a guide to the best craft beer you will not find it here even supposing anyone can agree on what it might be. The Guide varies in either ignoring entirely craft pubs or mostly listing them with reference to their cask ales. References to keykeg and keg dispense vary from refusal to note it at all to, mostly, referring to a ‘draught’ selection as well as the cask.

These selections and comments rely on local CAMRA branches to a great extent and while they may be idiosyncratic it’s fair to say that they both know good cask ale when they find it (good condition that is rather than good as such- that is much more subjective) and are not in any way paid by anyone for their efforts (as all other guides in some way do).

It’s a very bulky book now, too big to fit in the pocket and weighty in a bag so it’s good to see that at last a GBG App is being launched.
Protz’s influence can be seen in the Editorial pages at the beginning of the Guide in particular and while space is limited these they do indeed making interesting reading mixing as they do discussion of traditional cask with modern beer trends. One gets the sense that Protz is keen on CAMRA modernising (as am I) and indeed an interview in the Sunday People finds him in the Rake drinking a pint of 6.5% unfined (i.e. murky) Moor Hoppiness. I’m sure readers will get the point he is making.

There are some areas of the guide that do fall down badly I’m afraid. The breweries section includes perfunctory entries for brewers like Beavertown and Cloudwater. The former makes very little cask ale and the latter none at the moment. Yet they are both major producers of keykeg beers that CAMRA classifies as real ale. So how come these beers and commentary on them are not listed? Younger beer drinkers in particular looking at the GBG will find this very odd indeed, as it is.

Still one can always criticise. The GBG is testament to the work of Protz and CAMRA and without that the beer world as we know it would simply not exist. As Protz notes in the Sunday People interview when CAMRA started in the 1970s locally brewed beer (nearly all cask then) was on the verge of being wiped out by keg beer from huge breweries. The beer was not the craft keg we know now but Whitbread Wankard, Grotneys Red Barrel and the like. It was undrinkable then and would probably be unsellable now- hence ‘smooth’ and so on for the mainstream keg beers now.

If you are in an area you don’t know well and want a pub selling good cask (with potential mention that it also sells craft) then the GBG remains indispensable.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.