Articles

The price & quality of beer: would the Assize of Ale work in 2017?

In Uncategorized on September 15, 2017 by kmflett

The Price of Beer: Would the Assize of Ale work in 2017?

I’m in the process of writing more on the moral economy of beer around, price, profit and quality.

This will appear in due course on the Culture Matters site.

However there are wider questions that I won’t touch on in that piece.

One is whether the Assize of Ale, a way of controlling the price and quality of ale in Medieval times would work now.

I briefly touched on the matter earlier in the year here:

In summary the Assize performed several functions which are separate in modern Britain. It acted in effect as a way of licensing brewers and of licensing pubs. It also exercised quality and price controls on beer and imposed penalties for transgressions which might broadly be seen as akin to modern day duty.

The key features which it seems to me remain attractive about the principle of the Assize are twofold.

Firstly it had some sense of a ‘moral economy’ That is that there was a fair price for beer, that the beer should be of decent quality (and could vary in price depending on how good it was- and how much it cost to make). That there was also an expected rate of return for the brewer. Not necessarily a ‘profit’ but a return sufficient to allow the brewer or much more likely at the time, Brewster, to live decently.

Secondly that it was broadly democratic. The judges who sat in the Assize were not elected and the ale tasters who checked the beer were volunteers, but there was a sense that they acted in the interests of the community and not the wealthy in society. Of course this was only the principle, often not observed.

Hopefully the general attraction of a modern Assize of Ale can be seen but of course there are problems.

Firstly one of the best ways of controlling the price of beer is to adjust duty up, or preferably down. If the latter this not only reduces the tax take which (one hopes) is used to fund public services but understandably raises issues with health campaigners and leads to debates about minimum pricing.

Secondly an interventionist Government model on price and quality while it may seem attractive might well be bureaucratic, possibly maddingly so. There would need to be a strong element of local rather than central control, but that too is not without issues for anyone who knows how few people have time or interest to devote to such matters.

Thirdly no Assize of Ale is going to be able to control the likes of ABInBev or Carling which operate not locally but globally. They dominate the market. However their very domination is surely the very best reason for looking in detail about how the implementation of a modern moral economy of beer might work.

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.