From Profumo to Fallon: Tory Ministers and sex scandals
On 5th June 1963 the Tory Minister for War John Profumo resigned following a sex scandal.
Profumo (Harrow, Oxford, Bullingdon Club) had had a brief affair with a model Christine Keeler in 1961 who had also been involved with a naval official from the Russian Embassy. At the height of the Cold War these things mattered.
Tory Prime Minister Harold Macmillan hung on until October and then used a health issue as cover to resign.
The Profumo affair had been known for a good while before his resignation and Profumo had denied any wrong doing to the Commons.
As early as 28th March 1963 Tony Benn wrote in his Diary that he had a long talk with Dick Crossman about what he termed the ‘Profumo-Keeler’ scandal.
Benn notes that Labour leader Harold Wilson had written to Harold Macmillan warning that if Profumo was not removed from Office, Labour would raise the matter in the Commons.
Benn’s view was clear ‘I’m not in favour of private life scandals being used politically but it certainly makes the Government look pretty hypocritical’.
Benn kept to his word as well. He refused to join a BBC discussion on the matter when Profumo eventually resigned underlining that he didn’t think it was a useful thing to participate in.
50 odd years on Tory sex scandals are apparently of a different character but the result is much the same, including the hypocrisy. The Tories are far from the only party to be implicated in such matters but there is invariably a specific character to a Tory scandal, underlining the difference between the traditional values they claim to have and what they actually do.
After Profumo’s resignation the political discussion broadened.
Macmillan had clearly known the position but had done nothing about it. Benn thought that the situation was that Macmillan ‘must go’ but he would win a Commons vote to resign at once and leave in August 1963.
He did win a vote but he did not resign in August. Rather he left in October using the short term health issue as cover. A year later there was a Labour Government and Harold Wilson was Prime Minister.
Michael Fallon occupying the same Ministerial position as Profumo but now renamed Defence Minister, has resigned partly because it would appear he was unable to keep his hands to himself in the company of younger women.
Profumo left politics and worked as a volunteer raising funds for charity at Toynbee Hall in East London. It was widely recognised that despite his Tory background and the scandal that had forced out of him political life in the end he made a worthwhile contribution to society.
One wonders if the same will be said about Michael Fallon.
More broadly, as Benn noted in 1963 about Harold Macmillan, the Fallon resignation raises fundamental questions about the future of the current Tory Prime Minister Theresa May.
It seems likely that May knew about Fallon’s activities but only when these appeared in the public domain did anything happen.
Whether Tory MPs have now given May an ultimatum to depart and who might replace her is of course unknown.
In 1963 old Etonian relic Lord Home returned from the Lords to become Tory leader. That simply underlined the bankruptcy of the Tory Government of the time.
The Fallon affair belies something like Gramsci’s ‘morbid symptoms’ of a capitalist crisis. Unlike 1963 however the ‘new’ may be born rather more quickly, in the form of a Jeremy Corbyn Premiership, than the 14 months it took then.



It is a toxic working atmosphere, obviously, has been for decades…centuries…and one always wonders when “exposed”, what important matters are being quietly pushed through…