Malthus, Scrooge,Bob Cratchit’s Xmas Turkey & the Tory Government
It’s a while since I’ve eaten turkey at Christmas but in the mid-Victorian period it was something reserved for the well-off. The poor at goose or rabbit at Xmas.
Charles Dickens in a Christmas Carol (published in a de-luxe edition on 19th December 1843) had Scrooge (who he styled as Malthusian) repenting and providing money to buy his employee Cratchit a turkey.
Dickens book received overwhelmingly popular reviews on publication, with the exception of those who backed Malthus, those who believed resources in society were finite and as the population (of the poor) grew there would not be enough to grow round (for the poor).
The best example of this school of liberal political economists view of Dickens is probably that of William Bridges Adams, a noted railway inventor. Reviewing Henry Hengist Horne’s New Spirit of the Age (1844) for the Westminster Review (June 1844 issue), he sneered in passing at Dickens’s Christmas Carol.
The point made here is that unless turkeys are in surplus if Cratchit has a turkey someone else will go without. As generations of anti-Malthusians have noted, in effect, the simple answer is to breed more turkeys.
A great part of the enjoyments of life are summed up in eating and drinking at the cost of munificent patrons of the poor; so that we might almost suppose the feudal times were returned. The processes whereby poor men are to be enabled to earn good wages, wherewith to buy turkeys for themselves, does not enter into the account; indeed, it would quite spoil the dénouement and all the generosity. Who went without turkey and punch in order that Bob Cratchit might get them – for, unless there were turkey and punch in surplus, some one must go without – is a disagreeable reflection kept wholly out of sight.”
While I doubt there are too many Tory MPs currently in Parliament who explicitly endorse this view, in fact the ideology behind Iain Duncan Smith’s Universal Credit is very much in the same area. Rather than rely on ‘hand-outs’ from Government welfare or charity, the working poor are urged to find a job, because work will pay and allow them to provide for themselves.
You can imagine Chris Grayling happily pronouncing that if there are those who are going without at Christmas this is down to their own lack of effort and do-gooders and the left should keep out of it.



Leave a Reply