Articles

The strange case of Alastair Campbell & Haringey

In Uncategorized on January 26, 2018 by kmflett

The strange case of Alastair Campbell & Haringey

Alastair Campbell was formerly Tony Blair’s spin doctor and has subsequently published a series of quite detailed diaries which will be of help to future historians of the Blair years and make interesting enough reading now.

More recently he has re-launched himself as an anti-Brexit obsessive.

More or less in that context he has written a piece in Saturday’s Financial Times. It’s behind a paywall but Ive read it so you don’t have to (I subscribe, being a trade union officer in the City of London one has to know what the opposition are up to)

Campbell suffice to say still thinks New Labour was pretty good but the PFI so beloved of the Blair years has been found to have ‘weaknesses’ post-Carillion. In Friday’s FT the paper’s veteran columnist Martin Wolff goes much further arguing that PFI should only be used if there is a very clear case that it makes economic sense to do so.

Campbell of course does not like the left, Jeremy Corbyn or Momentum so in touching on Haringey he backs the current Labour leader Claire Kober. Well he would wouldn’t he.

He mysteriously suggests that Mr Corbyn is ‘more directly involved in events in Haringey than his team might suggest’. More mundanely Mr Corbyn is a North London MP and former Haringey Councillor and no doubt will have noticed as many have that while the neighbouring Labour Boroughs of Hackney and Islington have tried to manage pragmatically with the impact of a Tory Government, Haringey has developed a grandiose scheme to do so.

Campbell in respect of the controversial Haringey Development Vehicle claims that in the 2014 Council Election Labour promised to “build new homes and replace inadequate estates”. You can read the 2014 Manifesto here (not I suspect that many did):

http://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/labourclp97/pages/278/attachments/original/1399411540/Labour_Manifesto_2014.pdf?1399411540

It refers to ‘rebuilding Council owned Estates’ which is not the same as replacing them.

Campbell’s overall message however is that since Haringey voted 75% to remain in the Referendum on EU membership Mr Corbyn should forget about the HDV and get on with remaining in the EU.

That is some programme. Haringey to remain in the EU (despite the Referendum). A job of 45 minutes or so I’d think

Update

Alastair Campbell being who he is (or was) of course the FT piece was just the start of an onslaught against HDV critics and in defence of Claire Kober.

Campbell claimed on twitter that a survey had been done of 450 residents in Northumberland Park in Tottenham which is peak HDV and only a handful had been unhappy. I vaguely recall this event. I think residents were asked if they’d like their homes improved NOT if they’d like them demolished (see above, this is the difference between replace and rebuild)

Campbell then tweeted an extraordinary Shelter blog which claimed the HDV was ‘pragmatic’. What Labour Councils are doing elsewhere in London, a mixture of public and private house building fits that description. A scheme involving a multinational privateer perhaps not.

Finally some leaders of Labour Councils (few of whom can have a detailed idea of what the HDV is about) wrote to Rupert Murdoch’s Sunday Times complaining about the Labour NEC’s unanimous (note not Momentum but left and right) decision to ask Shadow Minister Andrew Gwynne to review matters.

I’m hardly an expert but I’m not sure there is a section in Labour NEC prodecures that requires those with a concern about a decision to write to the Murdoch owned press about it in the first instance.

As Sunday went on those signatories who are on Twitter tweeted the line that their objection to the NEC intervention was not about the HDV but about their ability to do things without being told what to do.

As Haringey LibDem Councillor Clive Carter tweeted not one of these Council leaders is of course proposing an HDV type arrangement, nor, obviously, could they give a monkeys about working-class voters in Haringey who face having their homes demolished (and most of them say so). They are concerned to defend their particular brand of right-wing Labour politics.

If I was a Labour voter in any of those Council areas I’d be very concerned if the Council leader said they wanted to ‘improve’ homes.

Meanwhile, on a more positive note the anti-HDV campaign have called a Haringey demonstration on 7th February. If you in the area (or a local person like me…) why not come along.

http://stophdv.com/category/events/#.Wm2q76hl_IU

Keith Flett is the immediate past Secretary of Haringey TUC and remains an active socialist and trade unionist

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.