After a demonstration on 7th February and a decision in a full Council meeting to stay any further moves on the Haringey HDV until after the May Council elections, the High Court has today ruled against the legal challenge to the HDV.
The judge says that many aspects of the challenge were out of time but is not persuaded by their merits either.
Gordon Peters who brought the case as part of the campaign against the HDV has said in a campaign mail:
We look forward to being in Appeal Court as much better chance of favourable judgement there, and could be precedent -setting for local authorities on how they make decisions, which would not have come out of this court.
The full judgement is here (thanks to Andy Wilson).
Click to access 20180208102033914.pdf
The judge notes that the HDV is ‘controversial’ but has confined the judgement as might be expected to legal points. I may be a socialist with a beard but I am with the late EP Thompson (and a bit less so with the late Norman Geras) in believing that the ‘rule of law’ is an important part of how a democratic society works.
That doesnt mean that specific judgements are not challengeable and Gordon Peters gives an example above. As an historian I might note that if the judge had found the HDV to be even more controversial than it was thought to be in Court the judgement might have found other grounds to reach a slightly different view..
In any case after the fudged Council vote on 7th February the campaign must go on. There is a useful report of that here:
https://socialistworker.co.uk/art/46084/A+chance+missed+to+bury+HDV+scheme+but+battle+continues



Leave a Reply