Articles

Haringey HDV protests, the London mob & the London crowd

In Uncategorized on February 11, 2018 by kmflett

Haringey protests, the London mob and the London Crowd

I didn’t see the tweet at the time but I note that Haringey Labour Councillor Natan Doron, who is standing down in May, tweeted about a protest at the Council meeting on February 7th over the controversial Haringey Development Vehicle that ‘There was a mob, with some Momentum faces that I recognised who booed & hissed..’.

As a Labour Councillor one would hope that Mr Doron would be a little more careful with words when dealing with the subject of protest crowds.

Understanding what happens when ordinary people decide to protest has been an issue for as long as the inequalities and divisions of market capitalist society have sparked the protests themselves.

This is really, at least in part, where the term ‘the mob’comes from.

It is used to describe a group of protesters about whom those in authority have little idea who, if anyone, might be leading them, and what they plan to do.

This worries those in authority but it is a function of large cities like London. It is possible in crowded urban areas for people to get up to all kinds of things without it being officially noticed.

Well off Victorians had a fear of the working classes living in areas adjacent to them. A concern that they might attack them or their property or both and then disappear back into the mysterious working-class areas from whence they came.

So for example in 1848 the cry of ‘the Chartists are coming’ was sometimes heard in well off London neighbourhoods, heralding an imminent invasion of protesters intent on creating havoc.

Needless to say, in the main Chartist demonstrations were orderly affairs. There were occasions, for example in early 1848, when Chartist influence was less, that less predictable protests took place.

Much the same fear underwrites current talk of ‘the mob’.

It is not an anonymous group in reality. It is a mixture of the more and less committed, of all kinds of ideas and strategies and on occasion none.

That is why the left far from using the term ‘mob’ has tended to refer to ‘the crowd’.

The pioneering work is by the late Marxist historian George Rude who wrote the classic text ‘The Crowd in History’.

It could be said that the difference between ‘the mob’ and ‘the crowd’ is that the former has sometimes been reactionary while the latter is generally progressive.

That is perhaps stretching an historical point.

Not all London mobs have been of the left and some attacked left-wing causes, for example during the period of the French Revolution in the 1790s.

But there is a tradition of left-wing crowds, from those who stood up for ‘Wilkes and Liberty’ in the 1760s, to the unemployed who marched and rioted in London in the 1880s and who formed an audience for the marxist Social Democratic Federation, right up to the modern day with the poll tax.

It could be said that the street protests and their often chaotic nature represent an absence of the orderly traditions of the labour movement. Or we might argue that they are a force that can be organised to achieve real change. A great start pointing for better things.

4 Responses to “Haringey HDV protests, the London mob & the London crowd”

  1. Quentin Given's avatar

    I agree Natan’s words were ill chosen. But I think the anti-HDV campaign now has a responsibility to spell out its alternative – conspicuously absent from the Stop HDV website and Fb page – that will build housing at scale to tackle urgent housing demand, deal with some of the appalling conditions in Northumberland Park and elsewhere, build the tax base (to avoid Northamptonshire-style meltdown) and avoid the right-to-buy (which will definitely hand social housing to the private sector, but which the HDV would have avoided). The LibDem £148 million pledge is tiny compared to what is needed. Labour is not quite looking like a government-in-waiting so true socialists have to deal with reality as it is, not as we would like it to be.

    • kmflett's avatar

      First law of holes stop digging: I would stop trying to suggest that in anyway the HDV is the answer to any problem. It is not. It would not be building houses any time soon and even if they were built they wouldnt be ‘appropriate’ no doubt for existing NP residents. The Scrutiny Committee went through detailed work on alternatives. Less dramatic and more pragmatic I agree but I thought that’s what reform was meant to be about!. As for Labour ‘not quite looking like a Government in waiting’ I appreciate that the current Haringey leadership didnt think this about Ed Miliband either. Not because he would necessarily lose, though obviously he did, but because he was too left-wing. I am definitely in favour of staring reality in the face and that tells me that local Councils with zero experience of dealing with multinational privateers like Lendlease are best not to do that. The very large private companies I deal with as a union officer do have that expertise and they struggle with these kind of companies themselves. As for the LibDems there I’m sure we completely agree.

  2. kmflett's avatar

    btw Im not sure exchanges in this kind of forum add much to the sum of human knowledge. Always happy to discuss over a beer at the Beehive. I am in favour of discussion & debate in the labour movement, with the enemy to be opposed on the right of politics

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.