Corbyn & Eastern Europe: the Corbynphobia moves on
With the written and tweeted apology from Ben Bradley MP on 24th February about Jeremy Corbyn’s supposed links with a Czech spy, the effort by the right-wing media and assorted Corbynphobics to smear him as being some kind of lover of or apologist for Eastern Europe tyranny has had to move on.
I wasn’t over enthusiastic about Danny Finkelstein’s piece in the Times (22nd February) but he did acknowledge that Corbyn was an anti-Stalinist. His point was that Corbyn being opposed to US imperialism was however and therefore a little softer on Eastern Europe. I don’t think this was Corbyn’s position (and I knew him in North London at the time) although there clearly were those who held something like it.
The problem is that it either overlooks or just cannot grasp the substantial group on the left who backed neither Washington or Moscow but thought that both needed changing in a leftwards direction. This I think is and was more Corbyn’s general position.
There is a somewhat less enlightening piece in The Observer (25th February) which if one were being charitable might be summarised as ‘did you ever wish you were better informed’. Having read it several times I’m not sure what it is really trying to say although I am well aware of where some of those commenting come from. Paul Anderson for example was a signatory to the pro-Iraq War Euston Manifesto (although he qualified his support). Susan Greenberg who was a journalist on the New Statesman notes that she attended a meeting of Islington North CLP in the 1980s and found some people talking ‘Leninist’ language (what is that? Unspecified) and some who supported Russia rather than Polish Solidarity. Well yes, it was a Labour Party meeting. All human life is there. What is not said is whether Corbyn was at the meeting or whether he expressed a view if he was.
Darren G Lilleker who has researched the subject of left links to Stalinism met James Lamond MP who was definitely a Stalinist and well known as one but his assertion that Corbyn was somehow soft on Russia is just that, an assertion.
Did Corbyn have a rigorous analysis of Russia as a degenerated or deformed workers state or as state-capitalist? I think not. He was a campaigning Labour MP and a very active constituency MP as well (and he still is). Marxist analysis was done by others (myself included).
I will say however that Corbyn was wrong in the 1980s about the importance of William Morris and I’m not sure he has changed his view since.



Leave a Reply