Articles

Christine Shawcroft, Momentum & trade unions: an echo of the Milibands

In Uncategorized on March 7, 2018 by kmflett

Christine Shawcroft, Momentum & trade unions: an echo of the Milibands

A Momentum activist, Christine Shawcroft, speaking in a personal capacity has called for the Labour Party to distance itself or perhaps even divorce itself from trade unions. The comment has a flavour of the moment both in terms of various decisions currently in front of the Labour NEC and in the context of the forthcoming appointment of a new Labour General Secretary.

However there is a wider back story here and Shawcroft’s comments echo something of what Ed Miliband was saying in 2013 and 2014, some of which in itself was not entirely unrelated to perspectives put forward by the late Ralph Miliband.

Below is what I wrote for the London Socialist Historians on the subject in February 2014

Historians say Ed Miliband’s Union proposals have echo of father Ralph

The London Socialist Historians Group who organise the socialist history seminar at the Institute of Historical Research in central London have said that Ed Miliband’s plans to change the way trade unions and trade unionists are represented in the Labour Party have an echo of his father Ralph, the late socialist academic, about them.

Mr Miliband’s proposals, revealed in an interview with The Guardian, would abolish the current Electoral College which elects the Labour leader. Instead a system of one member one vote would be used. Trade Unionists who pay the political levy to Labour would be encouraged to become registered members of the Party and given a vote.

The Labour leader has repeated his plan, first made in his speech to the 2013 Labour Conference, to add hundreds of thousands of individual trade unionists as active Party members.

The move would mean an historic change in the way Labour relates to trade unions. It would move away from the institutionalised link with trade union leaders and executives, reflected in the Webbs 1918 Constitution and partly replace this with a relationship with grassroots trade union members

In this Ed Miliband echoes in some respects the views of his father. Writing in the 1976 edition of The Socialist Register Ralph Milband in an article ‘Moving On’ about building a socialist political party argued that:

Clearly, the support of trade unionists is vital for the purpose. But that is not at all the same thing as an organic and organisational link with trade unions

Ralph Miliband’s point was that while left-wing and socialist parties across Europe had links with trade unions, the institutionalised link in the Labour Party was relatively unusual and not always useful in developing a radical politics

LSHG Convenor Dr Keith Flett, said While there is a similarity between the views of Ed and Ralph Miliband about how trade unionists should relate to Labour, history is all about context. 40 years ago Ralph Miliband saw the involvement of trade unionists as a way of overcoming the caution of trade union leaders and moving things in a radical direction. That could still happen of course. But in a period of relatively low working-class militancy the impact of the move might be to make Labour less rather than more radical in the short term

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.