How democratic does an Election have to be before it is accepted as being ‘democratic’
On 18th March Russia held a Presidential Election. The current incumbent Putin was returned for a further term with around 75% of the vote.
Many argued that it was not democratic at all, given that the main opposition candidate had been barred from standing, opposition parties had called for a boycott, and there were social media videos indicating ballot stuffing.
It can certainly be agreed that Russian democracy is not very democratic. The State is really run in the interests of and often by, wealthy friends of Mr Putin. Some have suggested that he would probably have won an Election run in the standard terms of Western European democracies. Perhaps, but he was making a point that he did not need to do that.
That said in some regimes that allow voting but don’t really encourage opposition, votes in the high 90% area for the winner are hardly unknown.
When Russia is criticised as being undemocratic (and on the evidence of Sunday it falls way short of any acceptable benchmark) there remains the issue of what model of democratic representation is in mind.
It took the UK almost 100 years from 1832 to 1928 to reach what might be called full adult suffrage. Does that mean that when the ‘Great Reform Act’ of 1832 abolished Rotten Boroughs and expanded the middle-class suffrage in some places the UK was a Parliamentary Democracy. The Chartists didn’t think so and nor later did women suffragists. Yet if you look at the political history of the UK it is often accepted that Parliamentary Democracy in the nineteenth century was much the same as it is now. It wasn’t.
Timeline of the development of Parliamentary Democracy (Constitutional Monarchy) in the UK
1832 – Representation of the People Act (the first ‘Reform Act’)
Extends vote to men meeting property qualification, reduces ‘rotten boroughs’ and redistributes Parliamentary seats to better represent urban areas
1867 – Representation of the People Act (the second ‘Reform Act’)
Extends vote to urban working men meeting property qualification
1872 – Ballot Act
Introduces the secret ballot at elections
1883 – Corrupt and Illegal Practices Act 1883
Effectively ended serious corruption in British elections
1884 – Representation of the People Act (the third ‘Reform Act’)
Addresses imbalance between men’s votes in boroughs and counties
1885 – Redistribution Act
Boundaries redrawn to produce equal electoral districts. Single member seats become the norm
1918
Women vote in a general election for the first time on 14 December with 8.5 million women eligible
1928
The Equal Franchise Act is passed giving women equal voting rights with men. All women aged over 21 can now vote in elections. Fifteen million women are eligible



Leave a Reply