Articles

From Atherton to Smith: trouble with cricket balls. A question of trust

In Uncategorized on March 24, 2018 by kmflett

I dont often blog about cricket, although I’m a keen fan and attender of matches. The exception, obviously, relates to beards. However today’s news that Australian player Bancroft and captain Smith have admitted that they, and others, agreed a plan to try and change the condition of the ball (with a view I think to getting it replaced) in today’s play in the latest South Africa-Australia Test is worthy of further comment.

The story is here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/43526870

Of course this is far from the first time that the issue of ‘ball tampering’ has surfaced in modern cricket. The was a well known case involving the then England captain Michael Atherton. Atherton denied that he was doing anything outside the laws of cricket and ultimately, rightly or wrongly, nothing further happened. That story is here:

http://www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/143193.html

The difference with today’s story of course is that Smith has admitted that wrong doing was planned.

I dont often refer to my work as a trade union officer (& I’m only going to touch on it briefly here) but it is relevant. I sometimes represent people who, rightly or wrongly, have been accused of doing something they shouldnt. Often the issue is, while rarely trivial, often relatively minor. In this case the episode of attempted ball tampering was actually farcical.

That however is not the issue. This is, if someone held in a position of trust by an employer (as Smith is as Australian captain) does something they know to be wrong, how can the employer be sure it might not happen again? If they are not sure how can they reasonably continue to employ that person? There are ways back from this- mitigating circumstances- but they are rare.

In short I’d say that Smith’s position as captain is likely to be held at some point as untenable. It is not about whether or not he is a nice chap. Nor is it about anything else he may have done in the past unless there is any evidence (so far none). Its about whether he can reasonably be trusted not to try breaking the laws of cricket again for potential advantage.

Of course we dont know the answer to that, he says not but that is always the worrying thing for an employer and the difficulty someone defending the individual has.

Will Smith actually be sacked? That is a little more complex because here contingency comes in to play. Is there a suitable replacement immediately on hand? If not he might continue until one is identified or until the noise around the matter becomes such that his sacking becomes unavoidable. See British politics for examples of both options..

Sunday Update

Matters have escalated sufficiently that the Australian Prime Minister has commented (and Boris Johnson surely cant be far behind now). Smith has been banned for a game (the next Test) by the ICC and Bancroft, in recognition of his relative youth and willingness to confess error admonished.

We await action by the Australian authorities, although Smith and deputy captain Warner agreed (not volunteered) to stand aside for the rest of the Test which perhaps unsurprisingly Australia lost heavily anyway.

The more interesting thing has been the news that a Leadership group, or some of it anyway, were involved in making the ball tampering decision and it seems quite likely that the Coach Lehmann also knew.

Smith has not volunteered information on this and indeed seems rather defensive. The doubt that raises is whether or not this really was a one off or a consistent practice. At the moment it is no more than a doubt (evidence is lacking) but that doubt also surely reinforces a concern (see above) that Smith and Co. might do it again

Anyway I’m obviously not making any of the decisions and my purpose here is really to raise some wider thoughts about how the world does or sometimes does not work that are perhaps not the headline stories in the media but are nonetheless worth a thought.

 

One Response to “From Atherton to Smith: trouble with cricket balls. A question of trust”

  1. Calvin's avatar

    Statement awaited indeed… It does seem astonishing – aside of the incontrovertible evidence and the wider questions of Smith’s continuing captaincy as an employee of the Australian cricket authorities to which you rightly point – that a team can openly confess to having cheated in the middle of a Test: and that Day Four can carry on anyway.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.