Articles

E P Thompson & the nerve of outrage

In Uncategorized on March 28, 2018 by kmflett

EP Thompson & the Nerve of Outrage

A Guardian Editorial on the Labour Party and anti-Semitism (27th March) argued that Labour leader did not have the ‘nerve of outrage’ around such matters. I don’t particularly agree but this is not the point of this post.

As the Editorial noted the term comes from EP Thompson, the 25th anniversary of whose death it is this year. He used the term in an essay, the Secret State which was collected in his 1980 volume Writing by Candlelight.

The reference in its specific context is a little problematic for reasons I’ll explain, but the hat tip to EP Thompson was in any case a nice touch (probably by Martin Kettle).

The relevant section of the Secret State is below. Thompson discusses the case of the 1966 seamen’s strike (John Prescott was a leader) and the then Labour Government’s view that the whole thing was a conspiracy organised by the Communist Party.

In the Secret State Thompson suggests that even by the late 1970s the matter had been largely forgotten and it should not have been.

He locates the origin of the nerve of outrage with the Freeborn Englishman of the early nineteenth century. This individual was prone to protest and even riot if he thought his (limited) civil liberties were being interfered with by the State or that the Government was embarking on unwarranted imperial adventures.

Unfortunately for the Guardian Editorial many ‘Freeborn Englishmen’ were significantly influenced by William Cobbett who was without question an anti-Semite.

Thompson’s complaint that the modern left had lost the nerve of outrage was not in anyway related to anti-Semitism but to his view (one I tend to share) is that the left just accepted that the State broke its own laws, trod on civil liberties and generally behaved badly because that’s what capitalist States do.

Thompson’s point of course was that be that as it may, protest was essential. And is still is.

Extract from the Secret State

Thirdly, I have recited this episode because, in its general outlines, it is now so familiar. The national crisis—the state of emergency— the deployment of armed forces— the attempts to induce panic on the national media— the identification of some out-group as a ’threat to security’— all these are becoming part of the normal repertoire of power. Of course, there are historical precedents for all these things; but never before, since 1816, has government been able to employ this repertoire without deeply and bitterly dividing the nation, and without inflaming the nerves of outrage and resistance in a minority— a minority which, by patient agitation and political education, has often been able to influence the majority, and, in the long run, secure some reversal of the pretentions of power. What is new, in the last two decades, is the dulling of the nerve of resistance and of outrage. Familiarity has bred contempt— not contempt for the state and for the specious alarms and rationalizations of power, but contempt for any possible alternative. And in this moment a new danger appears. For once the libertarian responses of the British people have been brought under sedation, then the reasons for the invisibility of the state within the state begin to lose their force. And so we see the evidence, in the present decade, of the police, the army, the security services, the quasi-official and the pseudo-private agencies of control, becoming more public, engaging in active ’public relations’, lobbying for new curbs on civil rights and for ’simplified’ legal process and attempting to familiarize the public with their intrusive presence. And, in the face of this new danger, the ancient historical nerve begins to throb once more. State Research is one of the evidences of that.

I will conclude by advancing some arguments which are, in part, addressed to my friends of the Left.  In doing so, I am bound to tread on corns, left, right and centre. So that I must insist, once again, that these comments are personal, and need carry no assent from the authors of this book.

A large part of the blame for the dulling of the nerve of outrage lies with the left itself. I do not make this as a wholesale accusation. There have been honourable centres of resistance, as in the long and dogged record of the National Council for Civil Liberties. We owe more than is often supposed to the vigilance of a few Labour and Liberal MPs, and even occasional questions from crusty Tory back-benchers. More recently, some journalists have been alerted to the dangers. And there are many others, among the splinters further to the left. But the resistance has been inadequate…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.