Articles

The resolution on craft beer & beyond that CAMRA narrowly rejected

In Uncategorized on April 22, 2018 by kmflett

The actual motion at the CAMRA members weekend at Warwick yesterday rejected as the 72.6% in favour didnt reach the 75% threshold is easy to find on-line. The reasoning behind it less so, which is why Ive pasted it below. As a CAMRA member since 1975 I voted for it on the basis that the world of beer is changing and the campaign needs to change too while of course retaining its core principles.

Media reporting has caricatured it as a discussion about whether CAMRA should back lager (I’d have no problem with that,obviously we are not referring to Carling or Fosters, they dont need any support from CAMRA,even if it were warranted which it isnt, they have huge marketing departments)

Anyway judge for yourself. And if you are not a member of CAMRA these are interesting times. Issues that go to the centre of what beer, brewing and pubs are about in the UK are being debated. Why not join and be part of that discussion in a democratic framework?

————————————————————————————————————————————–

SR6. To approve the insertion of the following Article 2(e) in CAMRA’s Articles of Association: “2(e) to act as the voice and represent the interests of all pub-goers and beer, cider and perry drinkers;”

Why?

  • The brewing landscape in the UK could not be further removed from the picture in the 1970s when CAMRA was founded – in 1973 there were fewer than 200 breweries, by contrast the 2017 Good Beer Guide lists more than 1,700
  • Draught beer in the 1970s was available in two broad categories: cask-conditioned ale and keg beer, the latter often made with inferior ingredients, lacking in flavour and devoid of character
  • Members’ testimonies and evidence from the sector show this is no longer the case, with British brewing characterised by innovation and dynamism, manifested not only in the variety of beer styles, but the types of ingredients used and the methods of dispense
  • Boundaries have been blurred and there now exist some keg and other non-cask beers that are high-quality products– brewed with first-class ingredients, matured over a long period, unfiltered and unpasteurised
  • The highest quality keg beers of today contain live yeast, are subject to secondary fermentation and are, to all intents and purposes, real ale up to the point when CO2 pressure is applied in the cellar
  • The consultation revealed many members find some of these products superior to lower-quality, mass-produced cask beer common in pubs – and members questioned why CAMRA champions the latter over the former based simply on dispense method and with no regard to the quality of ingredients, production or taste ● Producers have adopted the term “craft” as a marketing device which, while
  • CAMRA’s failure to acknowledge these developments risks failing beer consumers, but also at best ignores, at worst alienates, one of the most obvious, accessible and youthful potential audiences for real ale
  • With 80% of brewers and almost 70% of licensees saying they sold a greater proportion of “craft” keg beer than five years ago, the majority of members (including active members) polled said it was time for CAMRA to expand the scope of beers it recognises

How?

  • Position CAMRA as the representative and spokesperson for all UK beer, cider and perry drinkers and pub goers
  • Increase the knowledge and appreciation of the quality all types of beer, cider and perry
  • Lobby for a tax regime that favours drinking of beer, cider and perry on licensed premises
  • Forge strong links with other stakeholders, including brewers, licensees, pub owners, national and local government, professional bodies and amenity groups

Activity

  • Provision of beer-related information, educational activities and training opportunities to members, the public and those in the beer and pub sector
  • Campaigning to secure a long-term freeze or reduction in beer duty
  • Secure reform to small breweries relief to maintain growth and support investment

One Response to “The resolution on craft beer & beyond that CAMRA narrowly rejected”

  1. reallyoldhippy's avatar

    5 years ago “craft” keg beer hardly existed. So its not surprising that a lot more is sold now. If this rise has been so meteoric, why does it need the backing of CAMRA? The motion also skirts round the issue of what exactly “craft” beer is. Who will decide what “quality” ingredients are? Some keg beers might contain live yeast but the vast majority are dead as a doornail and need vast quantities of gas to revitalise it. If people think dead, cold, gassy beer is the future, they should start their own campaign for it. I’m sure they’ll get a lot of support from the big brewers.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.