What is the future of the Campaign for Real Ale as a Campaign?
The decisions made at the CAMRA members weekend at Warwick University have caused quite a bit of comment. There is dismay, which I share, at the failure to embrace craft together with some widespread misunderstanding of why that might be an issue.
My view is here:
Pete Brown’s take highlighting the crisis in cask ale and CAMRA’s apparent failure to grapple with it is here:
https://www.petebrown.net/2018/04/23/what-should-camra-do-now-to-save-cask-ale-and-itself/
I’m just a beer drinker but I am, and have been for many years a professional organiser and campaigner. It is the potential impact on CAMRA as a campaign that I want to highlight here.
CAMRA is what sociologists call a ‘social movement’ it campaigns for good beer, pubs, responsible drinking etc. It aims to change society a little bit for the better, at least as far as drinkers go.
Social movement theory which fills many volumes works on a basic model of campaigns. They develop around an issue or issues that attract in large numbers of volunteers who are activists and have the time and energy (and usually the youth) to build the movement. Think CAMRA in the 1970s.
As the social movement develops, at least if it is any good, it starts to have influence, maybe some activists become figures in official roles related (but not connected) to the movement. That broadly is CAMRA in the 1990s and early 2000s. It has an influential voice. Its views are quoted in the media and listed to by Government (whether acted on or not).
The third phase of the social movement is one of decline. Some believe that key aims have been achieved, others, getting older and finding other priorities, drop out.
Very few campaigns manage to avoid this model. CND is one that has. Founded 60 years ago it is still going. How has it done that? It has retained its core message (it wants to get rid of nukes) but it doesn’t keep saying that the Cuban missile crisis could lead to the end of the world. Rather it focuses on current threats- Trump- and recruits new younger activists who in turn shape it to some extent in their own image.
Now turn to CAMRA. There is a small hardcore of members whose view of good beer is the same as it was in the 1970s. All keg beer is Grotnys, cask is always best. This does not correspond to reality for many younger people who enjoy good beer and they I suspect see little relevance in CAMRA.
Why in this respect is the refusal to embrace craft beer such an issue? Craft beer, as Pete Brown notes, does not need a campaign. It is doing quite nicely without one. Indeed I frequently wish there had been a bit less publicity for craft beer events I attend given how rammed they are.
What CAMRA needs are the younger people who like craft beer. Why? Because they are the activists for the future. Just like people such as myself in the 1970s they seek good beer. Not good beer as it was in 1975 but good beer as it is now. Without those people CAMRA as a campaign risks joining the fate of most other social movements and declining to an irrelevant rump.
That is a big problem because just now we do need a campaign for decent beer. I’ll post further on that.



Leave a Reply