Articles

From Cobbett to Kober: the politics of the placeperson

In Uncategorized on May 5, 2018 by kmflett

From Cobbett to Kober: the politics of the ‘placeperson’

William Cobbett

Aditya Chakrabortty wrote a piece in the Guardian on the 2nd May to the effect that the Amber Rudd affair underlines that this is a Government based on short-termism with Ministers with no particular skill in anything except building their own careers moving from job to job. Indeed it resembles in some ways the pre-1832 administrations before the Great Reform Act that Cobbett called ‘Old Corruption’. Ministers were appointed not on the basis of capability but because of who they were, or who they knew and they used their positions purely to advance their own interests.

Just one day afterwards the former leader of Haringey Council Claire Kober announced on the day of the local Elections (Labour won in Haringey 42-15 seats) that she was taking up a job with the Pinnacle Group as Director of Housing. Pinnacle were one of the unsuccessful bidders for the contract for the Haringey Development Vehicle- a scheme to re-generate Tottenham- that proved hugely controversial and led ultimately to Kober’s downfall and departure as Council leader. Her Council seat was safely won by Labour on Thursday, The world moves on.

Cobbett thought the pre-1832 Great Reform Act world was one of sinecures and placemen. Those who held Office were not necessarily personally corrupt. Rather this was about people using their political positions to further their personal careers. It happens a good deal even if it is not a good look.

Kober’s switch from Council leader to property company has something of the same feel.

As Secretary of the Trades Council in Haringey throughout the Kober leadership years (Ive now stepped down although I am doing exactly the same job as a trade union officer) my job in part was of course to work with a Labour Council and her multiple tweet defence of her period as Council leader had merit even if it avoided the downsides and controversies. Perhaps those are for the memoirs.

In a time primarily of Tory and LibDem austerity the ability of a Council leader to do a great deal more than minimise the damage caused by cuts was limited.

At some point Kober and her colleagues had the more or less Maoist idea of breaking out of all that with a huge scheme to demolish a good part of North Tottenham and re-build it in conjunction with the multinational privateer Lendlease.

Neither of the local Labour MPs, none of the Borough’s trade unions and a significant minority of Labour Councillors (& some LibDems) were impressed and said so.

Ms Kober ploughed on. Quite how far it went will no doubt be reviewed by the new Council but hopefully (& I would not expect) anywhere near Our Friends in the North territory.

Even so I suspect William Cobbett would have recognised well the direction of the Council leadership in the last few years. For the few not the many. Hopefully after May 3rd things will change.

Aditya Chakrabortty on Amber Rudd

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/may/01/amber-rudd-career-elite-ordinary-people-contempt

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.