What is the issue with Big Beer?
As companies broadly termed Big Beer grow more active in the craft brewing scene in the UK, I note those who query what is so bad about Big Beer.
In a sense one answer might be nothing. After all, are small capitalists better than big ones? Not always.
In the UK AB InBev has acquired Camden Town brewery, Heineken has taken a 49% stake in Brixton Brewery (and also wholly owns Lagunitas which is fairly widely available in the UK). Carlsberg has brought the name of London Fields brewery. Meantime which was owned by SAB Miller before it was taken over by AB InBev is now owned by Asahi (who own brands like Peroni).
The current debate has been sparked by a story that Heineken (or perhaps someone else) plans to take a stake in Beavertown brewery. I have no further info on that, although the story appeared on the Friday before a Bank Holiday and was based on analyst info. Analysts are not my favourite people. Their job is to run stories about companies in the sector they cover which dictate market sentiment about a company and hence share price. Their stories are often mostly their own opinion or ‘take’ on an issue and while often having some factual basis also often contain significant errors.
Anyway according to social media since AB took over Camden their beers have improved. Since I presume they are brewed at the ABI funded state of the art brewery at Ponders End this is perhaps not surprising. Mostly its Camden’s core range that you see, and they’re not really styles I go for (either before or after takeover). They do occasionally produce interesting and excellent small batch one-offs. Indeed I note they are launching an IPL collab this week.
Elsewhere Roger Protz argued also on social media that since AB took control of Brooklyn brewery in the US Goose Island IPA, also widely available here, is far from the beer it was.
Not all Big Beer is as bad as some, but there are some fundamentals that remain important.
Big Beer has nothing as such against producing great beer (although it has no idea what that is and no interest in finding out). However what Big Beer is interested in is keeping costs of all kinds down, in order to maximise profit and in particular to maximise shareholder value. Public Companies have a legal duty to do that.
There is also the issue about how Big Beer runs-much the same actually as any large company. When a craft brewery is taken over or a significant stake in it acquired, usually a range of assurances are made about the beer being produced, freedom to brew whatever without Big Beer’s accountants getting in the way etc.
These assurances are genuine but they are only as good as long as the representative of Big Beer that made them stays around. Once whoever that is moves on (and that happens a lot) the new person in charge will have no idea what has previously happened and won’t feel particularly beholden to any previous assurances.
So what starts off being OK and working for both sides often starts to go bad quite quickly as the imperative of the bottom line asserts itself.
In short business is business and sentiment (analysts aside) doesn’t count for much.
My point to craft brewers considering external investment (for perfectly understandable reasons) as a trade union officer who has spent decades dealing with big companies (not in brewing, I just drink the beer) is: take care out there.



Leave a Reply