8th June 2017 General Election a Year On: From Corbyn to Gramsci
Electoral comparisons based on statistics without context or history tell quite a basic story.
Numbers made the point that well as Labour did on June 8th 2017 it didnt win which is the point. I’d say it is a very important point but not the only one.
Its worth, one year on, looking again at a comparison of how Tony Blair’s New Labour did in 1997 and how Jeremy Corbyn’s new, new Labour did in 2017
Seats
1997 418 2017 262
Increase in Labour vote from previous Election
1997 1.96m 2017 3.52m
Increase in % vote from previous Election
1997 8.8% 2017 9.5%
Labour had been expected to win the 1992 Election and (probably) the 2015 one, so the increase comparisons have some validity in that framework (there are of course others).
The difference is that between 1992 and 1997 the Tory vote collapsed. One might argue (and some do) that much of this was due to the construction of the New Labour project after Tony Blair took over as leader from the late John Smith. Perhaps but as likely it was because of a series of catastrophic failures by the Major Government.
It could be argued that Theresa May’s Government is having a good day if the worst they manage is a catastrophe but the Tory vote has held up so far. That said it took a good while after 1992 before the substantive decline in Tory poll ratings took place.
Perhaps the well-known reflection of the Italian Marxist Gramsci sums it up:
‘the old is dying but the new cannot be born’



Leave a Reply