Articles

Saying NO to Trump, London 13th July & frustrating the right to protest

In Uncategorized on July 12, 2018 by kmflett

I will be on the anti-Trump protest in central London on Friday and I expect it to be sizeable.

So clearly do the authorities (or the Establishment as some call them) since I note the London Evening Standard is already floating an attendance of 61,000 people. This seems to be based on Facebook indications of attendance but agreement about how large (or small) a demonstration will be in advance usually only occurs when there is unease about it.

For example the official view of the numbers attending the Chartist demonstration for the vote on Monday 10th April 1848 was 20,000 people. This had no relation to the actual numbers (certainly above 100,000) was agreed in advance and widely reported on the Tuesday.

Why there should be unease is less clear. Trump, in a rare display of prudence, will be nowhere near central London on Friday afternoon. It may just be that a very large protest might somehow permeate the consciousness of the ‘orange moron’ and cause him to make an uncomplimentary tweet.

In any case it has been reported that while permission has been given to fly the Trump baby balloon in central London in the morning the Met Police have withdrawn permission for a stage and a sound system in Trafalgar Square at the end of Friday’s protest. A matter one might think for the Mayor to sort out.

The wider historical point is that British ruling class which after all is the oldest in the world has generally preferred not to curtail rights to protest. That needs to be understood however in the context of the labour movement constantly pushing to maintain and extend democratic rights. For example when the Chartists marched in 1848 it was not legal to hold a meeting of more than 50 representatives without getting official permission.

We need only look at Friday’s protest to understand why in general it has been preferred to allow rather than prevent protest. Without a stage or sound system in Trafalgar Square there would be nothing to hold a potentially very large demonstration there. It might set off in various directions creating a policing nightmare.

That generally has been the historical view too. The authorities preferred to have protest where they could see it and indeed police it.

There have been exceptions and these have underlined that underneath the apparently benign position of allowing the democratic right to protest lies an iron fist.

The iron fist consists of heavy policing (historically the army was also used) together with judges who took particular views of how laws should be understood and implemented.

In 1848 the State arrested, very largely on as it were trumped up grounds, most of the leading Chartists and jailed them. Some demonstrations,  for example on 12th June 1848 at Bishop Bonners Fields in Bethnal Green, were banned and the police and army occupied the space to make sure.

In much more recent times the policing of the 1984/5 miners strike followed a very similar pattern. An official investigation into what took place at Orgreave is still too awkward it seems.

As EP Thompson had it: protest and survive

 

2 Responses to “Saying NO to Trump, London 13th July & frustrating the right to protest”

  1. gz's avatar

    apparently one has to get permission for marches, and a limit is set on how many one can have attending..

  2. kmflett's avatar

    there is a requirement to give notice and also a requirement to agree a route. Permission as such is not required. There is no limit on numbers who can attend

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.