Articles

Trial by jury, Ben Stokes & E.P. Thompson’s Freeborn Englishman

In Uncategorized on August 15, 2018 by kmflett

Trial by Jury, Ben Stokes and EP Thompson’s Freeborn Englishman

As at least those interested in cricket will have noted England cricketer Ben Stokes has been acquitted of affray after a 7-day trial in Bristol. He had been charged after an early morning incident in the City last September where fellow cricketer Alex Hales was also reportedly involved.

While Court reporters still exist fortunately, space for them to write a detailed account of Court proceedings appears to have departed. Hence while we learnt that the judge asked members of the jury if they were cricket fans and also how much Stokes had to drink on the night in question, we didn’t really get a full sense of what was going on in Court.

We do know (and these matters could only be reported at the end of the trial) that the Prosecution tried to substitute lesser charges than affray for Stokes at the start of the trial but the judge blocked this. We also know that at the end of the Prosecution and Defence cases the judge was asked to dismiss the cases against the defendants due to lack of evidence. One person walked free at that stage.

Stokes may reflect that it was probably just as well that he faced a jury rather than simply a magistrate. And it’s certainly just as well that he didn’t face trial by twitter or some sections of the media (the Telegraph appeared unhappy with the verdict, or perhaps just juries in general).

While the term self defence is… no offence, is a well known one in Tottenham where I live it is often combined with a healthy disdain for the chances of extracting justice from the legal system. Stokes was perhaps a little fortunate but no doubt too had a top legal team and ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ is or should be a stiff test to pass.

While the left is rightly often sniffy about judges and the law the reality is that the jury system is a cornerstone of democratic practice. Most can think of jury verdicts they didn’t like but the jurors heard and reflected on evidence which critics mostly did not.

Below is an extract from EP Thompson on the history of the jury system.  Ben Stokes and Alex Hales will face disciplinary action from their employer (we’ll see if their union rep is as effective as Stokes lawyer) but in respect of Bristol justice has been done in the democratic way.

 

The jury system is, to a social historian, a very remarkable institution. Beginning as a group of knowledgeable persons (or ‘inquest’), who could report their findings to the officers of the Crown, it has survived immense changes in political life and administration – not as a fictive or vestigial sign but as an active element in the judicial process.

During its 800-year life it has shed some functions and acquired others, evincing a quite unusual flexibility – from ancient juries of presentment, the homages of courts leet and baron, and the Regarders and homage of forest courts, to the formalities of the jury box today. Even more remarkable, it is an institution, or presence, or tradition – which is it? – which is in some part secret and impervious to research. The actual deliberations of the jury may not be disclosed, and sustained accounts of them are few and imperfect.

What, indeed, is the jury? A legal expert may tell us how it is summoned, and, less exactly, what are its powers. But a social historian cannot be so certain. To be a juror is to have thrust upon one a temporary office, to which is attached an inherited weight of rules, practices and expectations; and this weight transforms an office into an imposed (and often internalised) role. This role is exercised for a day, or a week, or for three months, and then as suddenly as it was adopted, it falls away once more. Seen in this way, the jury is less an institution than a practice, or a place amidst adjacent judicial practices: a place through which generation after generation flows, inheriting the practices of their forerunners, yet inheriting these with little formal instruction, and practising the role in the light of expectations brought with them into the jury box and shared by the public outside.

Extract from EP Thompson Subduing the Jury. London Review of Books 4th December 1986

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.