In the current issue of the New Statesman (link below, but buy a copy) Guardian journalist Aditya Chakrabortty reviews a new book by Adam Tooze on the 2008 financial crisis. He finds it a decent account but raises an important question in his concluding paragraphs:
Tooze prefers to look at the thousands of wrong-headed decisions than to explore some of the possible alternatives, and he is more likely to quote from a minister’s memoirs rather than reflect the experience of those people whose livelihoods are damaged by their decisions. Crashed focuses on what a decade of financial crisis meant for the Big Powers of the US and China. Yet look down rather than up, and you can see how financial globalisation coupled with austerity for the many and largesse for the few is breaking up the very unit of the nation state. Brexit Britain, Trump’s America: these are stories of deep fissures and polarisation whose causes are economic. And the anger is being channelled by the far right increasingly effectively: by Tommy Robinson, whose online videos garner hundreds of thousands of viewers and whose release was celebrated by singing on football terraces, and by Breitbart and Steve Bannon in the US.
The obvious riposte is to say that this isn’t the job of an academic. Tell that to Eric Hobsbawm or EP Thompson or C Wright Mills. There’s no point in being up to the minute if you won’t be relevant. There’s no jeopardy in chronicling the facts without telling the truth. Crashed is a brilliant book, but it is ultimately bloodless.
Chakrabortty is absolutely right. Eric Hobsbawm argued that socialist historians must ‘become historians of the present too’ while EP Thompson aside from campaigning against nuclear weapons produced a volume of articles and essays which brought his historical knowledge to bear on current events, Writing By Candlelight
https://www.newstatesman.com/2018/08/adam-tooze-crashed-decade-financial-crisis-review



Leave a Reply