The following piece on Peterloo appeared in the Daily Mail on 23rd August.
Dominic Sandbrook writes social histories of post-1945 Britain so we may take it that he is not a nineteenth century labour historian. Even so the vast majority of his account is tolerably accurate.
We can of course allow that he would not be writing in the Mail if he was a supporter of either Labour or Jeremy Corbyn so the argument that the Labour leader is not a democrat while Peterloo was about democracy can be safely ignored.
A lot more controversial is Sandbrook’s comment that the massacre was ‘almost certainly an accident’ albeit as he concedes the Yeomanry were likely to have been drunk.
Historical evidence does not provide an absolutely clear answer as to why the Yeomanry rode into the crowd on that August day in 1819 or indeed who was behind the order to do so. Whether it was just the Magistrates in attendance on the day or part of a wider strategy is unclear.
What is clear is that Peterloo was the result of class war. The business class of Manchester feared the working class and whether they could maintain their authority. They had, before the formation of a regular police force and local Government, very few instruments beyond the Army and the Yeomanry to do so.
If we understand Peterloo as a collision between class interests it is both difficult to see it as an accident and possible to understand it might happen again (after all such things do happen around the world on a regrettably quite regular basis).
But let’s return to the ‘accident’ point. Sandbrook might care to look up EP Thompson’s point in the Making of the English Working Class. Thompson wrote:
If the Government was unprepared for the news of Peterloo, no authorities have ever acted so vigorously to make themselves accomplices after the fact



Leave a Reply