Beyond Ian Bone: in defence anti-Parliamentary socialism
Ian Bone a veteran activist in the anarchist organisation Class War has caused ‘outrage’ in some parts of the media for turning up with others outside Jacob Rees Mogg house and briefly shouting at his children and nanny.
To my mind this is no more a legitimate political strategy that when sections of the media (the same ones mentioned above) used to turn up outside Tony Benn’s house in the 1970s and shout at his then children.
Still I wouldn’t get too excited about it. Class War has form and its been going since (at least) the 1970s. Its main purpose seems to be to attack the rich and powerful with the same kind of robust imagery that one finds in the cartoons of Martin Rowson and Steve Bell. Cartoons are of course an accepted form of critique. Doing things on the streets worries the authorities more.
Checking social media I find of course the usual saloon bar tweeters who think anyone to the left of Farage is a Communist and that Ian Bone must be a Corbynite.
It is a sad reflection of how far knowledge of the history of the anti-Parlimentary left has dipped beneath the horizon even on the left that no one much has corrected this. Of course Bone is not a supporter of Corbyn. He does not believe in political parties or changing things through Parliament or voting.
He stands somewhere (some might say on the edge) of a varied anarchist tradition ranging from syndicalism to libertarian socialism that sees change coming from below not through Parliament.
The origins of the tradition date back to the Socialist League in the 1880s which split from Britain’s first Marxist party the Social Democratic Federation (which was Parliamentary and was involved, briefly, in the formation of the Labour Party). The League didn’t have just one position on Parliament (obviously). There were those who were completely against Parliamentary action and those like Morris who saw the prime task as making socialists but wasn’t against putting pressure on Parliament ‘from without’.
A summary of Morris’s position is below.
It should be noted however that such currents have been more or less a constant theme on the left. After all Ralph Miliband’s Parliamentary Socialism (1961) queried whether Parliamentary action through the Labour Party really was the way to do things. Ralph never could quite make up his mind on that, unlike his sons.
To avoid doubt btw I am not an anti-Parliamentary socialist myself. No one who has spent as long as I have delving into the history of the Chartists (or indeed the Suffragettes) could deny the power of the vote. I remain an extra-Parliamentary socialist. Change can come through Parliament but fundamental change will require as William Morris noted movement from below.
William Morris on Parliament
…so that the Parliament and all other institutions at present existing are maintained for the purpose of upholding this slavery; that their wages are but slaves’ rations, and if they were increased tenfold would be nothing more: that while the bourgeois rule lasts they can indeed take part in it, but only on the terms that they shall do nothing to attack the grand edifice of which their slavery is the foundation. Nay more than that: that they are asked to vote and send representatives to Parliament (if `working-men’ so much the better) that they may point out what concessions may be necessary for the ruling class to make in order that the slavery of the workers may last on: in a word that to vote for the continuance of their own slavery is all the parliamentary action that they will be allowed to take under the present regime: Liberal Associations, Radical clubs, working men members are at present, and Socialist members will be in the future, looked on with complacency by the governing classes as serving towards the end of propping the stability of robber society in the safest and least troublesome manner by beguiling them to take part in their own government. A great invention, and well worthy of the reputation of the Briton for practicality – and swindling! How much better than the coarse old-world iron repression of that blunderer Bismark, which at once irritates and consolidates the working-men, and depends for its temporary success even on the absence of such accidents as a sudden commercial crisis or a defeat of the German army.
William Morris, The Policy of Abstention, 1887
https://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1887/policy.htm



Do you mean Jacob Rees mogg? Although true, his dad wasn’t very nice!
Thanks, yes. One Rees Mogg much the same as another in my mind clearly!