The Liberal Democrats & Liberal Party History. Are they related?
_________________________________________________________________________
Reviewing the history of the Labour Party in his collection Languages of Class the socialist historian Gareth Stedman Jones argued that it was largely an empty shell set to become whatever the inhabitants of the shell determined from time to time.
Stedman Jones may have had a point and some would argue that Tony Blair surely tested it to its limits but there is also a case for arguing that political parties have material roots which they can’t stray too far from.
This is a mere blog piece, if you like an historical provocation, so I’m not going to descend into the archives and footnotes but when it comes to the Liberal Democrats, it is surely possible to argue that their place in the political firmament is broadly known, going back through the Liberal Party to the Whigs with detours around Irish politics in the late nineteenth century and the Social Democrats in the late twentieth.
Obviously I’m on the left and I could fill several paragraphs with epithets about what role Liberals have played historically. It might make me feel slightly better but it won’t really help understanding.
To give you a flavour here is the later to be Chartist leader Bronterre O’Brien writing in the Poor Man’s Guardian on 25th October 1832 ‘the only difference between the Whigs and the Tories is this- the Whigs would give the shadow to preserve the substance; the Tories would not give the shadow, because stupid as they are, the millions will not stop at shadows but proceed on to realities
The Liberal Party, like all successful political parties in the British first past the post-election system has been a broad coalition. Certain things should unite all bits. A preference for peace over war (but not the First World War) for example and a support for temperance over the beerage.
Other elements are more partial. The Liberals have been seen as the party of middle class reform, although when you consider that this included the 1834 Poor Law Act which set up Workhouses as well as the legislation that started the idea of the Welfare State in 1910/11 it was clearly quite an elastic definition of reform.
It was certainly at core the party of middle class manufacturers originally shut out of the political Establishment by the Tory Party who represented the landowners. Precisely how the political representation of the British ruling class is configured has been the subject of lengthy debate starting with the argument over 50 years ago now between EP Thompson, Tom Nairn and Perry Anderson. I don’t plan to add to it here.
However before the arrival of independent political representation for Labour first with the ILP and then the LRC, the Liberals like the Tories sought to attract working class votes. They did not exactly embrace but certainly recognised the importance of trade unions. It was a strategy that worked and it led to a generation of Lib-Lab MPs and the survivors of the Chartist movement identifying themselves with the Liberals in the main.
Writing to Marx about the 1868 General Election on 19th November 1868 Engels argued that ‘everywhere the proletariat is the rag, tag and bobtail of the official parties’
In the late nineteenth century just as the fight for independent labour politics got going so some Liberals were involved in broad progressive and radical political alliances in major cities like London.
Like former leader Nick Clegg himself Tony Blair’s grasp of history was somewhat limited but this was probably what he had in mind with talk of a progressive majority in British politics. It is hardly my political cup of tea but you only need to look at the current political axis of US politics to see there could be worse things.
I think that some LibDem members and at least some of their voters have a fairly clear idea where the Party sits in British politics. However many members dropped out or left after the 2010-15 years, so it may be that a substantial section of the current membership do not have a view on where the party sits historically in British politics. That is the Stedman Jones perspective above
The Liberal Party heritage, as I’ve very briefly indicated above, is mixed as you would expect it to be. But that doesn’t mean that it can simply be ignored. Vince Cable’s attempts to somehow reinvent the party (again) will ignore history at the party’s peril.
Anyway there is an excellent Liberal Democrat history group that researches and comments on these matters and I’ll be looking out for their thoughts during the year.



Leave a Reply