Articles

Does Winston Churchill need rescuing from E.P. Thompson’s enormous condecension of posterity?

In Uncategorized on October 14, 2018 by kmflett

Does Winston Churchill need rescuing from EP Thompson’s ‘enormous condescension of posterity’?

Liberal-ish Tory commentator Matthew D’Ancona  is fond of quoting EP Thompson, who most certainly was not a Tory and he did so again in the Evening Standard on 10th October

Noting the phrase attributed to Churchill that history is written by the victors he called in aid EP Thompson’s view that the losers of history should not be subject to the enormous condescension of posterity.

Its quite difficult to frame Churchill has one of history’s losers. He had a State funeral in 1965. The point at issue is a dispute that arose after the UN Space Ambassador quoted Churchill on magnanimity in victory but suggested that this might not apply to Brent Kavanaugh the recently appointed US Supreme Court judge.

As a result the Ambassador, Scott Kelly was reminded that Churchill’s record was perhaps not, shall we say, exemplary.

D’Ancona goes on to argue that whatever view is taken of Churchill, his historical record should not just be ignored.

I’m not sure how much D’Ancona has read of EP Thompson but he makes the point in the Peculiarities of the English that while the left was no fan of Churchill, he was after all ejected by voters from Office at the first opportunity in 1945 (although he returned later) he had played a not unimportant role in the late 1930s. For example when Chamberlain was in favour of signing bits of paper with Hitler Churchill was in favour of fighting the Nazis. Just as well.

The historical point is one of nuance. No one in history, and this is the point Thompson went on to make in the introduction to the Making of the English Working Class from which D’Ancona quotes, is entirely a victor or a loser.  As Thompson noted causes that were lost in nineteenth century England might yet still be won elsewhere.

History remains in progress and is still being written.

https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/quote-churchill-at-your-peril-woke-ideologues-have-rewritten-history-a3958396.html

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.