Cricket Radio commentary: from TalkSport 2 to Test Match Special and the Cricket Social
As those who listen to ball by ball cricket commentary will know the BBC’s Test Match Special team has lost the rights for the current Sri Lanka v England series to TalkSport2.
I’m ideologically inclined to back TMS as public service broadcasting just as, I note, the Daily Telegraph is ideologically motivated to back TalkSport and criticise TMS (even tho TalkSport has a significant connection to the Murdoch media empire). Still I’m prepared to agree that ideology may not be quite everything.
TMS has by far the bulk of the radio cricket rights for the foreseeable future but the appearance of the TalkSport broadcasts does I suppose provide a benchmark for TMS.
I’ve listened several times now to both the TalkSport ball by ball commentary and the TMS’s cricket social (not at the same time). Last time TalkSport did cricket commentary (a South African tour) it was poor stuff. This time it isn’t. Combined and uneven development is at work. There are enough decent to good cricket commentators around for TalkSport to field a highly listenable team. Mark Nicholas even managed a brief mention of cake (no doubt a mild dig at TMS)
There were very few adverts and TalkSport is a commercial station so someone is paying (think Rupert) to get the cricket established with those that prefer their listening without adverts
The Cricket Social cant of course offer ball by ball and it could be argued (see the Telegraph) that it is based on the now departed Cricket Sofa. It is of course cricket chat, and interviews but it is considerably less laddish and rather more weighty cricket analysis wise than the Sofa was. It must be a challenge to fill such a long broadcast time with conversation (particularly as Geoffrey Boycott is not present) so it will be interesting to see how its sustained.
Too early for conclusions yet. I’ll be continuing to listen while keeping my personal and professional commitment to public service broadcasting still firmly in mind.



Leave a Reply