Articles

Beer for the many: what policy should a Labour Government have on beer & pubs?

In Uncategorized on October 22, 2018 by kmflett

Culture for the many, not the few: the importance of beer and pubs

In our social cultures of eating and drinking, we face the terrible effects of profit-seeking capitalist corporations, loading our food and drink with sugar, salt and fats, causing immense and increasing mental and physical health problems.

The power exerted by ‘Big Food’ and the problems caused by the monopolistic behaviour of the big supermarket chains are a real cause for concern; while the ‘food deserts’ that exist in many towns and cities are one of the key reasons why many lower income, working class people have such poor diets today.

These poor diets are often made worse by pressures from corporate capital, supermarkets and discount chains on people to consume too much alcohol. This leads to problems of physical and mental health, homelessness and crime, including violence in and out of the home, and money worries.

Despite this the pub is a central part of British cultural life, certainly for the many, but not necessarily fully inclusive even in 2018. Far from everyone drinks alcohol, for a range of reasons from personal preference, to cultural and religious belief. In addition pubs have been seen and actually were male centred environments – think of the Working Men’s Club- and people under 18 were not always particularly welcome.

On the other side there is what is known as the ‘tavern drinking’ school of social history. This is a subset of scholarship relating to the work of EP Thompson (who himself was certainly not adverse to visiting the pub). It sees the pub as a cultural institution of the left, very much in opposition to dominant and mainstream cultural forms.

One need only look at radical working-class history in the first half of the nineteenth century to see that from the Luddites to the Chartists the pub was a central meeting place. This was perhaps particularly so after the 1830 Beerhouse Act which led to a considerable increase in pubs, perhaps a little like the micro-pubs of today.

The idea of the ‘pub as the hub’ of local community activity has long been one promoted by the Campaign for Real Ale (CAMRA) CAMRA was  founded in 1971 to combat moves by the big corporate brewers to replace traditional cask ales with bland artificially carbonated keg beer. To its credit, its been one of the most success consumer campaigns of recent decades and  has also been active in trying to stop pub closures. Recent legislation in England, supported by CAMRA, allowing pubs under threat to be classified as Assets of Community Value (ACV) has helped and this would surely be one area which a Labour Government could look to strengthen in terms of legislative impact.

The wider and biggest issues that such a Government would have to grapple with however are arguably twofold:

1] How to make pubs genuine centres of community activity rather than places where people down as much alcohol as possible to their own detriment but to the profit of the drinks industry

2] How to make sure that the drink provided, beer particularly, is of a good quality and sensible price.

These two aims are surely complementary. Traditionally, pubs have supported a variety of social activities ranging from pub games through support for local music, theatre and other performing arts, to support for local football clubs and beer festivals. A pub which recognises its important role in the local community and offers well-kept beer at a fair price is far more likely to have a bright future and avoid becoming a casualty of the current wave of pub closures.

We need when looking at these two criteria to acknowledge that temperance has had and still does have a place in the labour movement. After all Jeremy Corbyn himself is certainly not a drinker. Indeed from Keir Hardie on Labour leaders have generally not been enthusiasts for alcohol, the exception being Hugh Gaitskell and Harold Wilson who drank brandy (and according to Private Eye the tonic wine Wincarnis).

There is a need to find a way between the ‘hardliners’ of Alcohol Concern, would certainly ban all drink if they could, (but see comment below on this) and the drinks industry that simply wants to make greater profits out of selling it.

Possibly the best available model is the Carlisle State Management scheme. It was introduced in 1916 both in Carlisle and in an area of Enfield with a view to controlling the drink consumption of munitions workers. It coincided with other measures to reduce pub opening hours generally and to cut the strength of beer. It took a good while to move away from the impact of both of these.

However there was a positive side to the Carlisle scheme. Good quality beer was produced at reasonable prices and before the 1970-74 Tory Government sold the brewery and pubs to Theakstons, Carlisle beer was revered by drinkers. The pubs themselves were also models of community use. Food was always available, while a close eye was kept on the consumption of spirits. Initially ‘treating’, the buying or rounds was also forbidden.

How would this translate into the modern day? A Labour Government could acquire a brewery and its associated pubs and use both to try and set a standard in terms of quality and price. Alternatively a State brewery could be set up, again with the idea of providing a template of best practice like Carlisle

Of course the impact on the wider drinks and pub trade would be limited so a Corbyn Government would also need to look at other measures. Controlling multinational drinks companies like ABInBev and Heineken is beyond any UK Government. However it should be possible to put a framework in place that would shift matters a bit towards drinkers and brewery workers.

A modern version of the Assize of Ale could be linked in to local licensing committees. They might also be charged with checking and regulating both prices and quality of beer sold, perhaps in association with activist groups like CAMRA.

Alcohol duty could be constructed in such a way as to both regulate the profits made by brewers and to make sure that fair prices were charged. Regulating the market in this way is no easy matter and again the Government could set the tone and benchmark with its own version of the Carlisle scheme.

But the key remains the promotion of the pub as safe environment for all, whether drinkers or not, This might usefully include consideration of how to reflect their traditional role in providing space for multi-generational engagement,  avoiding the social problems associated with the ‘vertical drinking establishments’ introduced in the 1980s in a cynical move to boost takings and ensuring pubs remain attractive to younger people . There are tensions here which are well known. Profit was not the motivator of the Carlisle State Management scheme but in the modern market dominated environment pubs that don’t make a profit close.

Again a Labour Government can address this and effectively downgrade the centrality of profit, by reducing business rates for pubs and where pubs are leased from breweries or pub companies, cap the amount of rent charged. They can also act to prevent ties which mean that wholesale drinks have to be bought at higher than market prices, then reflected in higher prices to drinkers, and which, incidentally, also exploit the publican.

Finally, in all of this, Labour would need to be prepared to push back the complaints of the ‘Beerage’, that unholy collusion between brewers and right-wing politicians which emerged in the 19th century, as many of the larger regional brewers or brewing groups are supporters of the Tory Party. Don’t expect any of the above to get a good reception in the Daily Mail. All the more reason to seize the opportunity to explore the counter-hegemonic possibilities offered by community institutions such as the pubs!

This post appears on the Culture Matters site. Thanks to them for some editorial improvements  to my MS!

 

 

 

 

 

 

One Response to “Beer for the many: what policy should a Labour Government have on beer & pubs?”

  1. Richard Piper's avatar

    Do please check your sources! As the beard-wearing pub-loving CEO of the charity formed from the merger of Alcohol Concern and Alcohol Research UK, we are manifestly not ‘hardline’ and would be horrified at any proposal to ban alcohol. Are you confusing us with someone else? We are not against alcohol at all and we are positive about pubs, which are a cornerstone of British culture. We are solely against alcohol harm, because millions of people are negatively affected by alcohol harm, due to either their own drinking or someone else’s. Abuse, neglect, drink driving, liver disease, stroke, domestic fires, domestic violence and other serious alcohol harms are all avoidable, with the right policies and practices, including from the mega-bucks alcohol industry. “How best can we reduce alcohol harm?” is the main alcohol-related question that a Labour Government should ask itself. And we can help it answer that.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.