Does marching make a difference?
A week on from the 700,000 strong march in London about Brexit media commentators are pondering whether or not marching makes a difference:
Ian Jack’s view is in the Guardian
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/oct/27/stop-brexit-peoples-vote-march
While the Mirror has a rather less pessimistic view
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/protests-peterloo-political-change-mirror-13482626
It’s appropriate to relate back to the 60,000 or so who gathered in central Manchester for the vote on 16th August 1819 because as the Mirror notes, while the immediate impact was negative over the following decades change did occur and the Government did not attempt another Peterloo.
I’ve been on many marches down the years from those opposing racism and cuts, to the Iraq War, the poll tax, abortion rights etc.
Some achieved little, others made quite an impact. Each one needs to be looked at individually to draw any general lessons. Certainly the composition of a march, the timing, and the strategy pursued to get change are key elements.
There are two wider points. Firstly marching is not the only way to get change. There is indeed what the US sociologist Charles Tilly called a repertoire of contention, of possible strategies, from riots to meetings, petitions and lobbies. All have their place depending on context.
Finally however on the 50th anniversary of the 27th October 1968 anti-Vietnam war demonstration its worth reflecting that all of the largest marches in UK history have taken place in the last 50 years.
It represents a change from people relying on others to make the point for them to wanting to make it themselves. Of course its not always effective but it reflects a society where want to make their voice heard and expect it to count. The age of political deference has gone.



Leave a Reply