Articles

The Spectator claims the People’s Vote march was 150,000 strong

In Uncategorized on October 31, 2018 by kmflett

Spectator claims People’s Vote march was 150,000 strong

The Peoples Vote March For The Future on 20th October 2018 in London, United Kingdom. More than an estimated 500,000 people marched on Parliament to demand their democratic voice to be heard in a landmark demonstration billed as the most important protest of a generation. As the date of the UKs Brexit from the European Union, the protesters gathered in their tens of thousands to make political leaders take notice and to give the British public a vote on the final Brexit deal. (photo by Mike Kemp/In Pictures via Getty Images)

I wasn’t on the People’s Vote march in central London a week last Saturday as I wasn’t in London (& I live primarily in London so I was out of the Capital for a reason).

I voted remain and I have sympathy with the idea of a People’s Vote on Brexit terms. I have no sympathy with just having another Referendum because some people voted the ‘wrong’ way last time. Frankly I’d prefer a General Election.

However while I want to make clear my view this is not centrally relevant to this post. According to Charles Moore in the Spectator (a pro-Brexit come what may organ) the numbers on the march were no more than 150,000. He has no evidence for this beyond his personal prejudice that there cant surely be that many people prepared to march on Brexit.

There can of course and while the 750,000 figure remains conjecture it clearly was a very large march. The time taken to reach the end point in Parliament Square (where it was reached) underlines the point as does photographic evidence.

Tories have form on this. They have been underplaying the size of protests since the Chartists gathered on Kennington Common on 10th April 1848 to demand the vote. They are still at it.

Charles Moore, The Spectator

https://www.spectator.co.uk/2018/10/george-orwells-legacy-has-been-monopolised-by-the-left/

If you think about it, it is obvious that The People’s Vote march last Saturday in London could not have been attended by 750,000 people, as its organisers allege. That is the equivalent of every man, woman and child in Edinburgh, Oxford and Cambridge (to take three Remain-voting cities). Sky News reported that the organisers claimed more than 500,000 (itself a preposterous figure), and by Monday this had swollen in most reports by 250,000. Only the Sunday Telegraph mentioned that such estimates are dubious. It was a big march, certainly (and mostly an amiable one), but visibly much smaller than the march against the Iraq war in 2003 (two million claimed by the organisers, probably more like 300,000) and the Countryside Alliance’s Liberty and Livelihood March of 2002 (organisers and police roughly agreed on 400,000). Of course, I do not know how many were there on Saturday (I would guess about 150,000), but nor does anyone. And that is the point. Earlier this year, I checked with the Metropolitan Police. They told me they no longer produce their own estimates of crowd numbers, leaving it to organisers to announce the figures. This cop-out (mot juste) makes it much more likely that the march’s numbers will be successfully exaggerated for propaganda reasons because there is no objective check. The police would be the right people to provide one because, for public order reasons, they need to know about crowd sizes, and they have the helicopters. Numbers are the most important propaganda element in almost any demonstration, yet they have been allowed to become fictional.

One Response to “The Spectator claims the People’s Vote march was 150,000 strong”

  1. Unknown's avatar

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.