Articles

Are the ruling class characters in Mike Leigh’s Peterloo caricatures?

In Uncategorized on November 2, 2018 by kmflett

Are the ruling class characters in Mike Leigh’s Peterloo caricatures?

William Hulton

Mike Leigh’s film of Peterloo is on general release from today and well worth 154 minutes of your time.

Some reviews have suggested, in summary, that there is too much history in it (speeches etc) and not enough massacre. I tend to think the reverse but that is for another post.

A related point is that the ruling class characters in the film, the Prince Regent, Lord Sidmouth (Home Secretary) Lord Liverpool (Prime Minister) and the Magistrates at Peterloo are simply caricatures and would not have been like that.

We cant of course be sure since 1819 is many years before any way of independently checking (film, interviews etc) existed. However while bourgeois politicians in 2018 are subject to mass scrutiny and in general have learnt to behave as human beings (Boris Johnson being an obvious exception) there was no such requirement two hundred years ago.

Contemporary accounts suggest that the Prince Regent was much as Tim Mcinnery plays him in the film. The chair of the Magistrates on the day, William Hulton, shown as signing warrants for the arrest of Hunt and orders to send the Yeomanry in was also the man who  The Guardian (formed in 1821 as a result of Peterloo) spent decades describing as a ‘foolish country squire’, although I’m not sure there is anyone currently working on the paper who is aware of that direct connection.

See the film for yourself as above but I think in so far as we have any means of judging Leigh does well with the portrayal of the bourgeois at Peterloo. I would say however that I’m not totally sure there is evidence that ‘Oliver the Spy’ had a beard.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.