Articles

The Economist on British history: a tale of Waterloo v Peterloo?

In Uncategorized on November 10, 2018 by kmflett

The Economist on British History: is it Waterloo v Peterloo

According to an article in this week’s Economist British history informs current political debates in this sense that while those who focus on Wellington’s victory at Waterloo are on the right those who mark the massacre at Peterloo 4 years later are on the left

The article is here (you may need to log-in, free)

https://www.economist.com/britain/2018/11/08/peterloo-v-waterloo-the-historical-divide-in-british-politics

There is or should be no divide over the events themselves. Both took place and are matters of established historical fact even if as ever there is always scope for new research into the detail. Rather it is the interpretation of what they meant and mean now that is key.

EP Thompson in the Making of the English Working Class made the point well:

We can no more understand the significance of Peterloo in terms of the local politics of Manchester than we can understand the strategic importance of Waterloo in terms of the field and the orders of the day’.

The two events were of course linked not just by the ironic reference to Waterloo in the use of Peterloo but because numbers of those who served at the former were present as protesters at the latter. They could fight for their country but not vote to determine the Government.

In essence the Economist argues that Waterloo shaped and continues to shape a particular view of the British State- successful militarily and distinct in its institutions and practices from the rest of Europe. Peterloo by contrast shaped a different view of Britain as an imperial state that although powerful had little time for the less well off, except when they were required to fight for it.

The wider point though is that Waterloo and Peterloo represent a shared history. Discussion and argument over what they mean is a normal part of democratic discourse. Or should be. Those who fought at Waterloo and protested at Peterloo live on the same island, as do those who gave the orders at both events.

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.