Fullers sells to Asahi: it’s not about beer
It may seem strange to say that the decision of Fullers to sell its beer business to Japanese brewer Asahi is not about beer.
After all Asahi will now own one of the bigger UK cask brewers. If its stewardship of Meantime is anything to go by I’d expect matters to continue much as before, and perhaps even improve a little. While we don’t have the detail Fullers have stated that they will have a beer supply arrangement for their pub estate which will certainly involve cask.
But that’s not what’s really happening here. Asahi have been collecting classic breweries because capital has a tendency to monopoly. Its interest in the UK initially related to ABIs purchase of Camden which allowed it to buy Meantime as a knock-on impact. According to the Financial Times (26.1) Asahi is still in the market for more acquisitions and Brexit does not overly concern it.
So we can, very generally, grasp what Asahi are about. They are building a global beer business although ultimately it could be a global widget business. They see it as a profitable activity which hopefully it is.
So why did Fullers sell? The beer business was not unprofitable. I don’t really buy the argument that progressive beer tax hit them. Probably it did, but not so badly that they made a loss. The Financial Times reports that operating margins had been under pressure since 2013 and had reduced by two-fifths to 4.5% since 2016. That still means the business was profitable, although the medium-term prognosis on the basis of that decline may have been more questionable,
However the pub business was much more profitable. As a company the Board have a legal duty to maximise shareholder value. That fairly obviously led to the conclusion to get out of brewing but stay in pubs. Shares in Fullers rose 21% on the news.
It is the logic of Thatcherism that has done so much damage to the social fabric of the UK in recent times. Whitbread are a classic example. They were brewers but coffee shops and hotels were more profitable. So the beer had to go. It’s the same logic that drives W H Smith, a newsagent, to tuck away the papers and magazines in its high street shops and sell sandwiches and any manner of other things which make more money.
But making money is not everything in life. There is nothing wrong with being a brewer that makes beer and obtains a decent profit for doing so. Of course bigger profits can be made elsewhere but is that the order of priority we want in our society?



Leave a Reply