The Fullers sale and the moral economy of beer
Many readers of this will be aware that Fullers, the largest independent London brewer, has agreed to sell its beer business (but not its pubs) to Japanese brewer Asahi.
There has been much comment (including my own) but this post is specifically about the sale itself.
John Cryne respected and long time CAMRA activist has called for a lobby of the shareholders meeting that will discuss the sale. Through an investment club some CAMRA members are shareholders in Fullers (I’m not one).
Beer writer Martyn Cornell (@zythothiliac) has suggested that the lobby is a waste of time and that the shareholders have acted in their own and the companies’ best interests.
Let me be clear here. With Company law as it is, that is correct. They have received a very decent offer for the beer business and if they had rejected it they would at best have had some explaining to do.
My issue is whether this is how it should or could be. I think not. Martyn thinks (& tweeted) that without the shareholders capital and risk there would be no brewery or beer. That’s not mainly the current shareholders, who are cashing in rather than risk taking obviously, but their predecessors. There have been and are different ways of funding breweries but in the case of Fullers (and many others) it has been about capital investment and a degree of risk for the investors (although limited by Company law).
However without the brewery workers and those that run their pubs and buy beer in them there would also be no Fullers.
That’s why when it was elected in 1997 Labour said it would change Company Law so that the duty of those running Companies was not just to maximise shareholder value but also to take into account the interests of workers and the wider community. It didn’t happen. But on this New Labour was right.
So the lobby of the Fullers EGM is appropriate in my view and after all the first letter in CAMRA stands for ‘campaign’. It won’t stop the sale but if it reminds brewers and others that there should be a moral economy it will have done a decent thing. To be fair a good many family and regional brewers do I think still have some sense of the point that while the bottom line is key (as Martyn Cornell again rightly notes) since bankrupt breweries produce no beer, there is still a wider sense of a long-established brewery as part of a community of workers and drinkers.



As a shareholder & long time friend of the company I think they are going about it the wrong way let alone selling to the Japs.If so much money had not been wasted on useless acquisitions in the last 5/6 years(over #60m.which have all lost money& buying in the shares at least#50m which masked the poor earnings pattern)there wouldn’t have been any need to sell,it just needed to be run a lot better.Now 400 workers(some 3 or 4 generational)will lose their jobs & the site will be redeveloped in due course(eventual value#1bn.) which shareholders get no benefit from.Youngs completed value in Wandsworth is approx #650m.I blame Simon Emeny entirely but the 6th generation families have taken their eye off the ball & are only interested in money!