Articles

Tony Benn on Winston Churchill

In Uncategorized on February 14, 2019 by kmflett

Churchill stamp design promoted by Tony Benn when he was Postmaster General. It doesnt contain the Queen’s head and it wasnt put into production!

How people are remembered (or indeed forgotten) changes in each generation but as can be seen from John McDonnell’s reference to TonyPandy, Churchill remains a controversial figure in Britain’s past

It is interesting to reflect how he was remembered at the time of his death in 1965 by Tony Benn.

Benn records in his Diary that Churchill had been in touch with the family in the 1940s and had been a supporter of his campaign to renounce his hereditary peerage and become an MP again in 1963.

Perhaps it is not surprising that on the day of Churchill’s death Benn wrote in his diary that he was ‘one of the greatest Englishmen of our time’. Partly Benn had not yet fully made the move to the left that he took in the 1970s. Indeed in 1965 he was Postmaster General in Harold Wilson’s Labour Government.

Benn records that politics would be put into ‘cold storage’ for a week and it was probably the case that Churchill  was the last political leader- partly because of his wartime role- where there was some degree of national agreement on the significance of his life and death. Certainly there were none of the protests and dissent seen when Mrs Thatcher died.

The Postmaster General’s first move was to approach Wilson with a plan to issue a commemorative stamp featuring the picture of the Queen and Churchill. It related to Benn’s campaign to remove the monarch’s image from stamps altogether and it is clear that even with a figure like Churchill, Wilson regarded the idea as doubtful.

Later in that final week of January fifty years ago Benn took his family to see Churchill lying in state at Westminster Hall. He notes that young Joshua Benn thought he was going to a Lyons Steak house and was perplexed as to who Churchill was.

Benn returned to this theme on the day of the funeral at St Paul’s Cathedral which he attended with Caroline Benn. He notes in his diary that ‘there were thousands of troops standing there and the crowds on each side were extremely heavy’.

His regard for Churchill notwithstanding Benn noted that the funeral made him feel uneasy. It was attended by an array of world leaders but Benn thought it the ‘last great Victorian festival’ and left as soon as decently possible.

Some might argue that 50 years on Britain is now a long way off the imperial era represented by Churchill, yet the State pomp and circumstance seen at his funeral is still very much part of the way the British Establishment goes on. The same monarch remains on the throne and politicians with very much the same kind of class and educational pedigree of Churchill himself sit in the Cabinet.

As the Sex Pistols noted in 1977 ‘there is no future in England’s dreaming…’

One Response to “Tony Benn on Winston Churchill”

  1. David Watts's avatar

    I grew up in Gilfach Goch, just over mountain from Tonypandy. I was born 1940 & recall in cinema newsreels in 1950s Churchill was always booed when he appeared. From what I’ve read no other British leader at the time could have led the nation to fully oppose naziism, the vilest creed to have disfigured Europe in a thousand years. However I find the recent adulation somewhat over the top, but fits in well with the outdated ideas of many Brexiteers. As for being the greatest Englishman I think not.
    As a Welsh man I think England’s greatest accomplishments are cricket, landscape gardening & Shakespeare which I hope will continue giving pleasure for hundreds of years.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.