Articles

Stuart Hall on how the media received the launch of the SDP (Marxism Today, April 1981)

In Uncategorized on March 2, 2019 by kmflett

The Independent Group (TIG) of MPs who have split from Labour and the Tories continues to receive mostly positive media attention, not least from the Guardian. Its worth remembering however that the paper’s Editorial line was to call TIG a mistake. Likewise while as Stuart Hall* points out below, some Guardian commentators were enthusiastic about the SDP, so much so that at least one joined and became a candidate (Polly Toynbee stood in Lewisham East at the 1983 Election) the paper’s Editorial line on the day the Limehouse Declaration was issued (26th January 1981) was critical:

The idea of a party uniting Left and Right, Heathite Tory alongside Gang of Three is an illusion. It would be a coalition of negatives’

Even so Hall makes good point about the SDP initially being a media construct (which was not the case by the 1983 Election to such a great extent)

The formation of the Council for Social Democracy (CSD) and of a Social-Democratic bloc in parliament, is, at one level, such a media-inspired and stimulated phenomenon, that it is hard to know how to make a realistic assessment of its electoral and political prospects. Its pragmatism, soul-searching ‘good sense’, the eminent ‘reasonableness’ of its leading figures, the agony of their hesitations, the renunciation of ‘doctrinaire extremes’, the rhetoric of’novelty’, are all calculated to project just that illusion of a viable centre, free of monetarist and Marxist ‘dogma’, dear to the centrist instincts of many sections of the press. Commentators like Peter Jenkins of the Guardian have been hoping and praying so long for this deliverance from the burden of Socialism, that it is impossible to know any longer whether columns like his represent sober political analyses or just more self-fulfilling prophecies. Pollsters and political analysts have been predicting the ‘swing to moderation’ for so long, that they might well have simply created Social Democracy themselves, if Dr Owen and Mr Rodgers had hesitated much longer. Rarely in recent memory has a political grouping looked forward with such confidence to becoming the decisive element in a hung Parliament on the basis of so sketchy and gestural a programme. The argument is that there is a vacuum in the centre which has to be filled. The CSD has so far responded to this challenge by being as vacuous as they could possibly be.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.