Articles

Taking back control 1604-1649-2019

In Uncategorized on March 18, 2019 by kmflett


Taking back control: 1604-1649-2019

The Speaker John Bercow has ruled out Theresa May bringing back her Brexit plan to Parliament for a third vote unless it is significantly different to the previous two efforts, both heavily defeated.

In doing so he quoted a precedent from 1604 and was duly slammed by some in the Tory Party, allegedly the party of tradition, for doing so.

1604 is a long time ago but it is, just, in the modern era.

In March 1603 King James had appeared on the throne as King James the V1 of Scotland and King James 1 of England and Ireland. Anyway he had a beard.

Relations with Parliament were not great from the outset. James wanted a union between England and Scotland which did not in fact occur until 1707. The Commons (see Christopher Hill, the Century of Revolution) declared that they held their privileges as of right and not due to the King, who in this period argued that he got the power to govern from God, the Divine Right.

There was much drama after that but the 1604 measure stopping the same measure perpetually coming before Parliament was in the same frame. It was aimed to prevent the King from having absolute power over the Commons.

In 2019 while Britain remains a Constitutional Monarchy and the monarch retains an interest in Parliamentary affairs the return of the 1604 measure is aimed at the battle not between monarch and Parliament but between the Executive and the Commons.

Parliament via Bercow is trying to take back control.

In the seventeenth century it didn’t end well for the monarch. After James successor Charles continued to claim the Divine Right to rule, Parliament formed an Army, the New Model Army under Cromwell and others, to enforce the power of the Commons.

On 6th December 1648 Colonel Thomas Pride carried out a purge of those MPs who were not loyal to the Parliamentary forces and on 30th January 1649 Parliament definitively took control as King Charles head and his body became detached from one another.

I doubt it will come to that in 2019 but Theresa May would do well to heed tradition as should befit a Tory PM.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.