Articles

Once again on the size of protests: the People’s Vote march 23rd March

In Uncategorized on March 21, 2019 by kmflett

Once again on the size of protests: the People’s Vote march 23rd March

The march to remain in the EU in central London is clearly set to be large. The organisers have already stated that 200 coaches are booked to bring people from out of London. Quite how large it turns out to be will inevitably be a matter of debate

As an historian I have a professional interest in the size of crowds that goes back to work on the Chartist demonstration for the vote on Kennington Common on Monday 10th April 1848. It was the first to be captured photographically and the first where the size was deliberately underplayed by the media and the authorities. It was agreed in advance to report 20,000 had attended and that was duly done. The actual attendance was upwards of 150,000 although certainly not the 500,000 claimed by Chartist leader Feargus O’Connor.

As an activist as well as an historian I also go on marches. I was on the Stop the War march in 2003 and indeed one of the (many) organisers. That was well over a million and so large that two departure points were required. It was said, I think broadly accurately (although there is always scope for research) that anywhere certainly in England and Wales if someone had not been on the march themselves they would have known a friend or work colleague who was.

I was not of course on the Countryside Alliance march in 2002 which apparently had 400,000 people on it but I think it fair to say that the number was impressive because not that many would have come from London. Indeed there is still no Tottenham hunt to this day.

Traditionally the police underestimated the size of protests and organisers overestimated (see the Chartists above). The police have given up estimating size probably because they no longer have the resource to do it. In addition it is a fiendishly difficult job. Not everyone who starts a march finishes it (some go the pub etc) while not everyone at the finish will have marched the whole way.

Any really large protest in London (but see the Countryside Alliance above) draws most of its support from London. There is a limit about how many people coaches and trains can bring into the Capital on a weekend. The People’s Vote twitter account for the last Remain march on 20th October 2018  noted that ‘100s’ of coaches brought people from outside London to the march. Assuming they were full (50 seats) that might account for 10,000 people. Trains will have brought more but this still leaves the bulk of the 750,000 (the organisers estimate seems to have finally been 570,000)) making it from around London.

As with Kennington Common in 1848 disputes arise about precise numbers attending. It clearly was a very large march. One social media comment suggested that the most Parliament Square (the end point for the march) could accommodate at any time would be around 220,000 people. Quite possibly, but they would not of course have all been there at the same time. Marches are about people moving not remaining static (that’s a rally). That said for the maximum photographic impact of such a march the end point of Hyde Park would have worked better. The route is however a matter for the organisers and the police depending on a number of variable contingencies.

I voted Remain but will be watching Saturday’s march with a professional interest

One Response to “Once again on the size of protests: the People’s Vote march 23rd March”

  1. Unknown's avatar

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.