Once Again on the size of the People’s Vote march on 23rd March 2019
I was not able due to other commitments to pay more than passing direct attention to the People’s Vote in central London on 23rd March.
As might be expected I’m no fan of the named organisers but that is hardly the point. A very large demonstration brings all sorts of people and ideas onto the streets and opens up possibilities.
The organisers pre-claimed the march would be a million strong and repeated that afterwards as well. To be fair with such a large march over a relatively short distance ending up in a restricted space it’s very difficult to tell. My general views on the size of protests are here:
Once again on the size of protests: the People’s Vote march 23rd March
There were some slightly odd claims. One twitter post showed the Mall full for a Royal event in a previous summer and claimed this was the march. Who knows what that was about. Likewise there was some twitter comment that the police had said the march was 1.5-2 million strong. I could find no verification of this and it was also odd because in recent times the police, mainly I think for resource reasons, have given up attempting to assess the size of protests.
There were as ever agendas running. One was that it was the biggest ever UK protest, bigger than the 2003 Iraq War march. I think it’s fair to say that this line was largely promoted by those who ignored the 2003 march at the time.
A right-wing commentator claimed that protest marches are never as big as they were claimed to be, probably I suspect because they can’t cope intellectually with the possibility that large numbers can mobilise for reasons they don’t like.
My thanks to Hazel Potter for drawing my attention to a further estimate based on the views of Professor Keith Still at Manchester Met University.
https://fullfact.org/europe/peoples-vote-march-count/
Professor Still is an expert in crowd science, risk analysis to you and me, and by the look of it does valuable work in this area:
I’m afraid however it is of limited worth in assessing the size of protests, for which some history and some social movement theory are probably more important than crowd science.
Anyone who has attended protests over the years will know that the biggest risk, depending on what the protest is, is not the numbers attending but being whacked by a police officer.
That said the use of the well-known crowd formula of no more than 2 to 4 people per square metre (it was square yard back in the day) really does not give accurate protest numbers.
The historian David Large applied it to the Chartist demonstration for the vote on Kennington Common on 10th April 1848 and came out with a number so low that it almost rivalled the official estimates which were simply made up beforehand to minimise the impact of the protest.
I doubt if the March 23rd gathering was as large as the 2003 Stop the War Iraq which needed two different departure points to make sure it got going at all. I’m not sure it’s a competition.
More relevant is that ALL the largest protest marches in British history have taken place since 1968 when the October 1968 anti-Vietnam War demonstration was considered the largest ever at a claimed 100,000. Perhaps this is a more interesting thing to ponder than precisely how large the People’s Vote protest was, beyond very large.



Leave a Reply