Articles

Big Beer: is it back to the 1960s?

In Uncategorized on March 30, 2019 by kmflett

Big Beer: is it back to the 1960s?

Roger Protz has noted of the strategy of Big Beer: “First Big Beer buys up a swathe of independent breweries. Now it’s attempting to control the natural ingredients used to make beer. The power of these global behemoths is frightening and has to be vigorously resisted….

Big Beer is on the march, and we risk losing our wealth of choice to merely the illusion of it. Not only are consumers being misled, but these global brewers are changing the very character of the beers they buy and driving genuine independents out of business….

The question of what the strategy of Big Beer in the 2020s has been sharply focused again by Kirin’s takeover of Magic Rock with more buy-outs rumoured.

I agree with Protz that the aim of Big Beer is to control the market and in doing so to mass market beers which will claim to be ‘craft’ but will be of lower quality and more bland than ‘genuine’ products. That process will usually take time. It is the outcome of a series of decisions that big businesses make about cost savings and efficiencies in order to retain or boost profit levels (EBITDA).

It would be a mistake I suspect however simply to expect a re-run of the 1960s. In that period regional and smaller brewers, often those which had failed to invest or keep pace with changing markets for various reasons (but not always) were swallowed up and closed. Their beers, or at least their best-selling beers, were produced elsewhere in much larger breweries. At the same time the Big Six, Watneys, Whitbreads and the like sought to monopolise not just beer production but beer sales. They did that by growing pub estates and making sure only their products could be obtained in wide geographic areas- Watneys in East Anglia for example.

I don’t think the 2020s will look quite like that. For a start Big Beer is now definitively global. It has no specific interest in shutting down a brewery it buys and brewing the beer elsewhere because where would that be? Nor does it have a huge interest in owning pubs. What it does have an interest in is making it financially attractive for pubs to carry its products and not those of genuine independents.

Moreover unlike the 1960s its not really about reducing beer ranges and promoting a few big brands. These already exist. The problem is that the profit to made out of them by Big Beer is not as high as it was, while the profit out of the (much smaller) craft beer market is higher.

The Big Beer combination there then could be to reduce the cost of making craft beers they acquire (and in doing so make an inferior product) and to seek to make them as widely available as they can.

That means of course not just pubs but supermarkets, restaurants, cafes. The shape of the beer market looks a bit different in that respect to the 1960s.

A preliminary summary might be (and these are very preliminary thoughts) that the broad trends that Big Beer pursued in the 1960s remain but that the context of the 2020s is somewhat different.

What is missing in the above is the input of an independent campaigning voice for beer drinkers. CAMRA arose out of the impact of Big Beer in the 1960s. Its still around but can it, or others grapple with Big Beer 2020s style?

 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.