The size of the crowd : the Chartists on 10th April 1848
Estimates for the numbers attending demonstrations tend to vary a lot from, low side (the authorities) to high side (organisers) and getting a sense of the reality is invariably awkward. Splitting the difference is not the answer.
In terms of 10th April 1848 when the Chartists assembled on Kennington Common for the vote there is a very well-known photograph of the rally but it is widely accepted that this was taken before the attendance peaked.
David Goodway’s in his book on London Chartism 1838-48 notes that there was a sort of official campaign by those in authority to claim that the rally was only 20,000 strong and numbers of papers the following day repeated that. The Times reported the most liberal estimate as 50,000 people
The organisers on the other hand, including O’Connor, claimed 400,000 or 500,000 which was as absurd as the 20,000 figure. The population of London in 1848 was around 2.2 million so that would have meant around 25% of the entire Capital showing up. The National Chartist Convention estimate was 250,000 while Goodway mentions an estimate of a freelance reporter working for The Times TE Fowler of 200,000.
A number of leading Chartists on the day thought the figure was 150,000 and Goodway on balance supports that.
It was clearly a sizeable demonstration, but it was not the size that allowed the authorities and subsequent historians to paint it as a failure. Rather it was the alleged failure of the Chartists to storm Parliament or seize power that, in the context of the European 1848, suggested this reaction. Plus of course the frenzy of concern the authorities had got themselves into about the possibility.
I have found a letter from someone (not apparently a Chartist) who did a calculation based on the then size of Kennington Common to work out likely numbers attending. It appeared in the Northern Star on 29th April 1848 and I’ll post further on that
The Chartists had not planned revolution for 10th April. Their aim was to deliver a mass petition for the vote to Parliament. That was done, but not quite in the way they intended.
Even so 171 years ago on Monday 10th April 1848 took place the first demonstration in UK history that was large enough to warrant an argument about the numbers attending and in 2019 we are still at it.



Just curious… why is it thought the 1848 photo of the rally was tsken before the crowd peaked?
[…] https://kmflett.wordpress.com/2019/04/10/the-size-of-the-crowd-the-chartists-on-10th-april-1848/ […]