Articles

From 2014. An exchange on the upsides & downsides of Julian Assange

In Uncategorized on April 11, 2019 by kmflett

Below is an exchange from 5 years ago (March 2014) on the upsides and downsides of Julian Assange, together with a commentary by myself. Wherever you draw the balance extraditing a whistleblower to the US would be regarded historically as an affront to William Cobbett’s Freeborn Englishman (Assange of course is an Australian). More on that elsewhere

Andrew O’Hagan and Colin Robinson on Julian Assange: how lucky did capitalism get?

Whether you like, dislike or couldn’t care either way about Julian Assange Andrew O’Hagan’s piece in the LRB about his experiences when he was contracted to ghost-write Assange’s autobiography make fascinating reading.

http://www.lrb.co.uk/2014/02/21/andrew-ohagan/ghosting

If you’re not familiar with the story, the book didn’t get written and Assange was not happy. Neither I suspect was O’Hagan

There are some wider points to be picked out of O’Hagan’s account.

Firstly that Assange and Wikileaks genuinely did have material that was seriously embarrassing and worse for numbers of Governments. Not just difficult because it revealed awkward things but because it indicated things that really should not have been done at all.

O’Hagan notes an attempt via Tariq Ali and Verso to systematically edit and present the material in a series of books. Unfortunately it didn’t happen and not due to them.

A summary of O’Hagan’s view of Assange’s personal behaviour is that he is self obsessed. The detail is sort of entertaining although anyone who thinks that some things they do might not seem odd when viewed at close quarters by a third party might usefully think again.

Details here include not doing the washing up and not using utensils to eat dinner with. Somewhat unreconstructed one might venture. If one was kind.

The overall impression here though is of one of those 1960s and 1970s radicals who older readers may remember who were in public certainly of radical intent but in private much less so.

Finally there is the point, as O’Hagan notes, that Assange surrounds himself with ‘yes’ people and certainly no one older than himself with more experience who might venture a critical thought or two.

In other words here  Assange’s working practices were in one of the dominant neo-liberal/managerial frameworks of our time.

In short, at least on Andrew O’Hagan’s account, when it comes to Julian Assange, capitalism got lucky.

However in a response in The Guardian Colin Robinson, Assange’s current publisher, has perhaps raised the question of exactly how lucky capitalism got

http://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/mar/06/julian-assange-publisher-defence-wikileaks

Before we judge Assange  Robinson argues we should consider several factors. Firstly he faces the possibility of jail [on several counts one might add]. Secondly it is likely that various agencies of various States have an interest in spreading malicious stories about him [O’Hagan is clearly not part of that]. Robinson suggests that anyone faced with such pressures might well behave a bit oddly. That can clearly be accepted.

Robinson also suggests that far from being someone who never really seemed to complete anything useful, Assange did in fact manage several important matters during the period O’Hagan refers to.

Up to a point fair enough.  I don’t think it takes away from several important points that O’Hagan makes however. Firstly that Assange did not pursue the chance with Verso to systematically organise and publish the information Wikileaks has. Secondly that, particularly given his situation, he did not either work with a team of people who had the ability to overrule his judgement on occasion, or appoint someone to oversee the project to take some pressure off himself.

After all as the Lego Movie tells us, Everything is Awesome, everything is cool when you’re part of a team. While this is a piss-take on managerialism, the left doesn’t have a tradition of genuine collectivity without reason. Relying on heroes doesn’t work. They can do heroic things but they are inevitably, probably as a result, flawed.

One Response to “From 2014. An exchange on the upsides & downsides of Julian Assange”

  1. Unknown's avatar

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.