Articles

David Starkey, historian, opines again

In Uncategorized on April 12, 2019 by kmflett

David Starkey, historian, opines again

David Starkey the right-wing controversialist and historian has been on the BBC again, On this occasion he was disagreeing with Ash Sarkar from Novar Media about Jeremy Corbyn.

Starkey is well-known for his right-wing views and hence is no fan of Corbyn but is this anything to do with him being an historian? I think probably not.

Starkey studied the Tudor period at Cambridge under Geoffrey Elton (yes he was related to Ben Elton) and went on to produce studies on Tudor monarchs and sixteenth century Royals. He lectured at the LSE and then did a good deal of TV work around his specialist area.

So Starkey is a serious historian and indeed I’ve heard him speak at an academic conference where he stuck to history and it was fine.

Does his work in Tudor history have anything to do with his prejudices about Corbyn? I rather doubt it and if it does Starkey has never said what the relationship is. How about Henry V111 had a beard and so does Jeremy Corbyn? Hmmm

I’m also a research historian specialising in nineteenth and twentieth century labour history. It’s a vast area and my actual specialist subject is Chartism and post-Chartism. Ive researched these in detail (and continue to do so) so I can speak with authority on them. That’s very far from saying my views are unchallengeable by the way.

I’m in favour of historians bringing an historical flavour to present day discussions but I do think that if that is done then some kind of historical link does need to be demonstrated.

The challenge to Starkey then is if you are described as an historian and want to attack Corbyn, what is the link?

Dr Keith Flett convenes the Socialist History Seminar at the Institute of Historical Research, University of London School of Advanced Study.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.