How E P Thompson dealt with veteran wine drinker Roger Scruton
The veteran right-wing wine drinker and far right thinker Roger Scruton has been complaining that those of like minds are being silenced. We could be forgiven for not noticing particularly as his most recent complaint was made on Radio4’s Today programme.
In 1985 Scruton published a book, Thinkers of the New Left, which was widely criticised and quickly remaindered. One of those he criticised was the historian E P Thompson, who died in 1993.
Thompson responded in the London Review of Books in a particularly effective way. He passed over Scruton’s largely specious criticisms of his historical practice and focused instead on the implication that he was not in any case someone who was really left-wing because of his alleged wealth. An extract from what Thompson wrote is here:
I was browsing in a bookshop the other day and came across a book by one Roger Scruton about Thinkers of the New Left. It included biographical notes on these Thinkers, of whom I turned out to be one. To my excitement, I found myself described as a man of ‘considerable wealth’.
This was welcome news, and I must write to this Scruton to find out where this wealth is and how I can get hold of it. Perhaps he knows of some fortune about to come to me? Because all that I know is that my net income from all sources – that is, literary and some lecture fees (and I have no other sources) – in 1985-6 was £8,653.62 before tax. That is not poverty, but it is not, I think, what is normally regarded as ‘considerable wealth’ by characteristic figures in Mrs Thatcher’s Britain, such as directors of Guinness and the like. Perhaps even Mr Scruton does a little better? But I find on scanning the dust-jacket that this Scruton is a philosopher, who need not pay regard to inconvenient things like facts. He is engaged in loftier heuristic exercises.
London Review of Books 7th May 1987
Its worth noting that the original book caused such a furore that it was withdrawn by Longman. A revised edition, Frauds, Fools and Firebrands appeared in 2015 minus the personal attacks on the like of Thompson, although still very critical.
Recent controversies involving Scruton however indicate that the personal attack is a part of his intellectual mode of operation and in responding in the way he did, gently mocking rather than attacking Scruton, E P Thompson set a benchmark for how to respond



Leave a Reply