Articles

From John Profumo to Gavin Williamson: how Tory Defence scandals end up

In Uncategorized on May 2, 2019 by kmflett

From John Profumo to Gavin Willamson: the bottom line for Tory leaders in Tory Defence scandals

John Profumo

The sacking of Defence Secretary Gavin Williamson (University of Bradford) over the leaking of information about the Chinese telecoms company Huawei to the Daily Telegraph (he denies the leak, at least at the moment) raises the spectre of the Profumo Affair which took place just within living memory in 1963.

There are similarities, some differences but I suspect what is likely to be a very similar bottom line.

Its not clear what information Williamson allegedly leaked to the Torygraph but its unlikely to have been earth shattering. The context was twofold. The first was Williamson’s (now departed) ambition to be Tory leader. The second was that while the UK Government can apparently live with Huawei (which is in essence run by the Chinese Government) helping to construct a 5G network the US (which shares security with the UK) is much less happy.

The crucial point in the Williamson affair then is likely to have been the fact of the leak, a matter of trust.

In a sense the Profumo Affair was similar. John Profumo (Harrow and Oxford) was Secretary of State for War (they called a spade a spade in the early 1960s). He was involved with a younger woman Christine Keeler who was also friendly with a Soviet naval attache. This was the era of the Cold War. There was no suggestion that Profumo had given Keeler any secret information. The matter again was one of trust.

While Theresa May sacked Williamson who denied his guilt, Profumo, aided by the Tory Government initially tried to cover matters up. Only when Labour leader Harold Wilson made it clear to Tory PM Macmillan that if nothing was done the matter would go public did Profumo resign. As the Guardian appreciation on his death underlines he later did much to redeem himself.

A few months after Profumo resigned Macmillan stood down as Tory leader. It was officially claimed that it was a health issue (which did exist) but in reality he could not continue after being aware of the cover-up.

One suspects that May who is already on borrowed time as PM will find that the similarity between Profumo and Williamson as a bottom line is that its not only the Minister who has to go but the Prime Minister too.

 

 

 

 

 

Wiki on Profumo

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Profumo

Guardian appreciation of Profumo from journalist who covered the affair

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2006/mar/10/guardianobituaries.conservatives

One Response to “From John Profumo to Gavin Williamson: how Tory Defence scandals end up”

  1. John Walker's avatar

    Wasn’t the point about Profumo’s resignation that he lied to the House of Commons, having previously told the House that there was “no impropriety” in their relationship? His lie was revealed by Keeler revealing the “Darling” letter to the press.

    Incidentally, the post of Minister of War was not the same as the post of Secretary of State for Defence. Profumo dealt purely with the army.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.