Articles

Eric Hobsbawm & E P Thompson

In Uncategorized on November 21, 2026 by kmflett

Eric Hobsbawm & E P Thompson

The publication of an important new intellectual biography of Eric Hobsbawm by Emile Chabal has sparked new interest in his work. Along with the biography is a new bibliography which underlines how extensive Hobsbawm’s work was (and how influential).

I have always been in the camp of E P Thompson as the British Marxist historian whose insights have learnt most from.

I met Thompson on several occasions at meetings and socially and while we did not entirely see eye to eye politically (he thought I was an anarchist) he was an engaging person.

By contrast while I heard Hobsbawm speak I never met him.

It can of course be argued that Hobsbawm and Thompson had different politics. Both members of the CPGB until 1956, Hobsbawm stayed a member until closing time in 1990 while Thompson was closely associated with the first new left. He remain a Marxist but a heterodox one. Both however shared a popular front perspective on politics reaching back to the CP in the 1930s.

I found and find Thompson’s work on the moral economy and the ‘Freeborn Englishman’ and civil liberties both historically and politically interesting.

By contrast it was the insight into historical detail that drew me to Hobsbawm. The Invention of  Tradition, a collection he edited with Terence Ranger remains an important work. His vignettes on cloth cap wearing, golf courses and football (we still don’t know if he was an Arsenal fan) to name a few are fascinating.

Politically I did not agree with Hobsbawm’s Forward March of Labour Halted but then I didn’t agree with Thompson’s European Nuclear Disarmament. Not that this was wrong of course but it was a diversion from class politics.

Perhaps at this distance we can pick and choose insights from both but it remains a pity that there is no biography of Thompson. His papers are locked up at the Bodleian of course which presents a considerable difficulty.

Thompson’s peace campaigning has left the bigger political mark I think but Hobsbawm’s role in Past and Present remains important in the academy. The work of both has been influential across the world.

Lastly we may ponder that both historians, partners and families had holiday cottages in North Wales and there is a record of them both attending the same New Year’s Eve Party. If only social media had then existed we might know what they talked about..

2 Responses to “Eric Hobsbawm & E P Thompson”

  1. Gregor Gall's avatar

    Of John Foster’s review of the new Hobsbawm bio (in the Morning Star this week https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/how-historian-can-get-it-wrong):

    At some point over the previous decade Hobsbawm appears to have abandoned Marx’s own definition: that the working class included all those who have to sell their labour power to subsist — with “labour” being a process in which hand and brain are integrally combined. … It was why, in the Age of Empire, he makes the strange announcement that the only period when a numerically dominant working class existed in Britain was the 1890s — because there was then a majority of manual labourers, culturally identified by uniformly wearing cloth caps and eating fish and chips. … No wonder then, for Hobsbawm, that the “forward march” was well ended by the 1970s and hence the left needed to look elsewhere for “new social forces.”

  2. kmflett's avatar

    agreed. Hobsbawm’s view of the working class was fixed in stone and there is work around now that follows that pattern too!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.