Claire Kober, Haringey, competence, ideology & pragmatism

The Haringey HDV saga is probably boring a good number by now, although what has happened in a North London Borough does have a wider significance. Haringey isn’t really the centre of the universe unless you’re a fan of Spurs or Beavertown beer or both in which case it might be.
Anyway the outgoing leader of Haringey Council Claire Kober who resigned on Tuesday after apparently refusing mediation with a Shadow Minister over the controversial Haringey Development Project has written a defence of her years as leader in the New Statesman:
https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/staggers/2018/02/if-labour-undermines-pragmatic-leaders-me-it-our-communities-lose-out
There is also a lengthy interview in Saturday’s Guardian.
I was Secretary of Haringey TUC throughout Ms Kober’s period as Leader (I stepped down in January for a range of reasons but mainly because I’m busy and I’m 61 and really is time for someone who can take Haringey trade unionism forward over the next 10 years, while I spend time combing my beard and so on).
I never once suggested Ms Kober was incompetent. Far from it. Indeed, and I appreciate this may not be popular but I’m no fan of rewriting history, we agreed on a fair bit.
We agreed that the impact of the Tory/LibDem Government from 2010 and the Tories alone from 2015 was making life very difficult indeed for ordinary people in Haringey. There were cuts in funding that impacted on essential services and the Tories cared little. Addressing this was central for a Labour Council but there were no easy ways to do so.
We also agreed that the scale of issues in Haringey meant that something really had to be done.
Where we did not agree, as it appeared, was that something like the HDV would help.
There is an issue with housing in Haringey (lack of affordable housing) but the HDV was never going to do much if anything about that. The plan was to demolish a fair bit of housing that was quite liveable in (certainly far from slums) and replace it, via multinational privateer Lendlease, with new homes. Quite how affordable any of these would be never seemed to be clear. Just this week Guardian journalist Aditya Chakrabortty was pressing the Council on this but I don’t think he got a comprehensible answer.
Anyway the demolitions would actually make the housing crisis worse not better in the short and medium term.
Here we need to broaden the political canvass a little. At a social occasion before the 2015 Election a bloke with a beard (who subsequently went on to higher things like leading the Labour Party) queried to me why Haringey could not do what Islington Council was doing. That is to say a pragmatic mix of private and public activity in the housing area. Headline stuff it isn’t really and it can ever do enough to address that scale of the problem, but it is doing something.
It was pragmatic not ideological.
The alternative of course was to get the Tories out and return a Labour Government committed to public spending and public housing. Of course it could not be relied on. Labour has lost 3 elections from 2010.
It is however still a far better strategy than relying on Lendlease to sort you out.
The bottom line here is that the leadership of Claire Kober in Haringey while of course supporting and campaigning for a Labour Government were not really that enthusiastic about the matter. They are certainly no fans of Jeremy Corbyn, but I’m afraid Ed Miliband was also too left-wing. So to them the big strategy was not a change of Government but a change of perspective to a privatised Haringey.
Labour as Ralph Miliband pointed out in Parliamentary Socialism is above all an electoral party and it must be said that this strategy of privateering does not seem one that is likely to be particularly appealing to potential Labour voters.
Some one will say (indeed have already said) that a Council with some Momentum supporters on it will do no better. We shall see. It could hardly do worse. The record of house building under Ms Kober’s leadership is shall we say, not impressive.
Keith Flett stood down as Secretary of Haringey TUC in January 2018. He remains an active socialist & trade unionist, living in central Tottenham