Articles

Is Jeremy Corbyn a Marxist? The view of Karl Marx

In Uncategorized on April 4, 2019 by kmflett

Is Jeremy Corbyn a Marxist?

According to Iain Duncan Smith Jeremy Corbyn is a Marxist. I wouldn’t put down Duncan Smith as an authority on anything. I’ve known the Labour leader for the best part of 40 years and while I can plausibly claim to be a Marxist (the Guardian have described me as such after all) I’m not sure it would be uppermost in how the Labour leader sees himself. Socialist and beard wearer might be closer. As with Tony Benn he understands the importance of Marx but he is possibly not the go to person to explain the complexities of the Marxist dialectic (see T A Jackson’s classic volume for that).

Indeed I might as a Marxist describe Jeremy Corbyn as a left-wing social democrat. Its not an insult but at base it covers the point that he places a good deal more emphasis on change coming through Parliament than I would (after all he has been a Labour MP since 1983).

In not being a Marxist Jeremy is however in good company, that of Marx himself. The great beard wearer towards the end of his life disagreed with the emphasis on reforms in the 1880 programme of the French Socialists. He believed that the fight for reforms was a genuine one not just a way of popularising the alternative of revolution.

He declared: “ce qu’il y a de certain c’est que moi, je ne suis pas Marxiste” (“what is certain is that I myself am not a Marxist”).

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1880/05/parti-ouvrier.htm

On that basis perhaps Jeremy Corbyn could claim to be a follower of Marx but not a Marxist. Don’t expect Iain Duncan Smith to comprehend the difference

Articles

Cask 2019: does cask beer have a future

In Uncategorized on April 3, 2019 by kmflett

A somewhat delayed post on the excellent Cask 2019 in Bermondsey a few weeks back

Cask 2019

Megan Davies and myself paid a rare visit to the place known as Sarf on Saturday for the second Cask festival, organised by Affinity brewery (and no doubt others).

We were at the first festival in 2018 and my impression is here:

https://kmflett.wordpress.com/2018/04/09/cask-2018-if-it-tastes-good-drink-it/

This year it was Testbed on the well known beer destination of Druid St. It was busy but, the key point, toilet arrangements for both women and men appeared adequate.

It was however about the beer not the toilets and there was an excellent range of cask beer ranging across styles from dark mild, sour, gose, murk to imperial stouts, and with that a range of strengths from 3.5% to 10% (ish).

Every beer I tried (in halves) was at the least decent and certainly in good condition. I’m not sure it works to identify favourites when you have a range of styles but I did particularly enjoy a cask version of Beavertown’s Luploid IPA. If the Tottenham brewers are pondering as others like Cloudwater have already done, a return to some cask production that would be an excellent start.

Unlike in 2018 I’d say the world of what I suppose might be called craft cask has moved on. Last year some of the beers I tried were in the category of, a decent attempt and drinkable but not top notch. This year the list was well curated and I certainly nothing that had the taste of an experiment about it.

Does this mean much in the wider scale of things? I noticed a smattering of CAMRA members present (some I suspect even as old as myself) and it may be that this is where the craft/real ale crossover really starts to happen. If some of the better known craft brewers can get well kept cask beer into bars that don’t major on keg, then the world of beer drinking will have improved for the better.

Articles

Socialist Historians call for reinstatement of suspended Ruskin College UCU rep

In Uncategorized on April 2, 2019 by kmflett

London Socialist Historians Group

2nd April

Media Release

Contact: Dr Keith Flett 07803 167266 Twitter @LSHGOfficial. Website: http://londonsocialisthistorians.blogspot.co.uk/

Socialist Historians call for reinstatement of suspended Ruskin College UCU rep

The London Socialist Historians Group which organises the socialist history seminar at the Institute of Historical Research as the University of London (currently suspended in support of an IWGB boycott over outsourcing) has backed calls for a suspended UCU rep at Ruskin College to be reinstated.

Lee Humber the UCU membership rep at Ruskin was suspended on Monday, details are below.

The historians say that Ruskin has a long association not just as a trade union college but also with socialist history itself. The late Raphael Samuel one of the founders of the History Workshop movement and journal was a tutor there.

LSHG Convenor Dr Keith Flett said, this is not how we expect Ruskin College to carry out its affairs. Whatever the detail of the issues at stake, and its clear they are serious and go beyond Mr Humber’s trade union activity, they should be sorted out by discussion and negotiation not ill conceived disciplinary measures

__________________________________________________________________________________

Ruskin College UCU Press Release

Reinstate Dr Lee Humber – University College Union (UCU) Representative at Ruskin College

On Monday 1st April, 2019, The Principal of Ruskin College (Paul Di Felice) suspended Dr Lee Humber who is a UCU representative at Ruskin College. The suspension, on bogus charges, came after an overwhelming Vote of No Confidence in the Principal by Ruskin College UCU branch. Tragically this is not an April fool’s joke and comes at a time when Ruskin College is supposed to be celebrating its 120th anniversary as a College that has strong links with the labour and trade union movement in Britain and internationally.

UCU is calling for the immediate reinstatement of Dr Lee Humber and for the bogus charges against Lee to be dropped.

We urge everyone to send emails to the Principal (pfelice@ruskin.ac.uk) and Doug Nicholls, the Chair of the Ruskin College Board of Directors (dnicholls@ruskin.ac.uk) asking for the immediate reinstatement of Lee and clarification of why a trade union representative has been victimised by Ruskin College.

Messages of support and solidarity should be sent to the Chair of Ruskin College UCU (dmcdermott@ruskin.ac.uk).

 

 

 

Articles

Best day in UK politics for beard wearers since 1902 as May negotiates with Corbyn on Brexit

In Uncategorized on April 2, 2019 by kmflett

Beard Liberation Front

Press Release 2nd April

Contact Keith Flett 07803 167266

Best day in UK politics for beard wearers since 1902 as May negotiates with Corbyn on Brexit

The Beard Liberation Front, the informal network of beard wearers, has said that the decision by Theresa May to enter talks with Jeremy Corbyn about a Brexit deal represents the best day for beard wearers in British politics since 1902.

Corbyn has won the Parliamentary Beard of the Year vote for a record 8 times:

https://kmflett.wordpress.com/2018/12/07/jeremy-corbyn-wins-parliamentary-beard-of-the-year-title-for-record-8th-time/

The campaigners say that while the last Prime Minister to wear a beard, Lord Salisbury who resigned in 1902, was a Tory since then the best any Tory leader has managed in the way of facial hair has been a moustache and this was phased out after Harold Macmillan.

Theresa May is not believed to be personally pogonophobic, having had Nick Timothy in his hirsute period as an advisor, but there is no doubt that she has paid undue attention to the group of clean shaven men in suits called the ERG

BLF Organiser Keith Flett said, the reality is that in 2019 Beard Power matters in politics and Theresa May has at last been forced to recognise it.

Articles

Jacob Rees Mogg, History Man & the German AfD

In Uncategorized on April 2, 2019 by kmflett

Jacob Rees Mogg, History Man & the German AfD

The hard-right Tory MP Jacob Rees-Mogg, spends his time as a businessman investing abroad while pushing for Britain to leave the EU. He also displays Victorian social attitudes.

Rees-Mogg father William was Editor of the Times whose most useful public act was to try and prevent the sale of the paper to Rupert Murdoch.

William graduated with a history degree and Jacob did the same from Trinity College, Oxford.

Little might be thought of Jacob Rees Mogg’s upper second-class history degree were it not for the fact that he makes quite regular historical comparisons with current events while making interventions on the EU debate from, of course the perspective of the hard right.

A number of well-known MPs in recent years have held history degrees. George Osborne for example had one, although he displayed as much historical knowledge as did economic while Chancellor- that is none. Gordon Brown, also had a history qualification and to his credit had both written some labour history and showed some historical sense.

Rees-Mogg is in a slightly different class in the sense that it is difficult to work-out whether his occasional historical pronouncements are in fact related to historical knowledge he gained while studying for his degree or simply off the cuff comments.

His most recent foray into history is difficult to excuse or explain he retweeted a comment by the German far-right to fascist party the AfD which was Islamophobic in comment.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/fury-tory-jacob-rees-mogg-14217758?utm_source=twitter.com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=sharebar

Later on LBC he claimed that his RT was because it was important that people know a German view on EU related matters. The point being of course is that it is not a specifically ‘German’ view it is a specifically racist one (Stephen Yaxley Lennon could be heard spouting much the same in Whitehall last Friday) and as an historian Mr Rees Mogg should know the danger of uncritically circulating such points.

His previous recent forays into history are detailed below

His first historical comment on Theresa May’s Brexit plans was that they risked splitting the Tory Party in the way Peel had done in 1846 over the Corn Laws. Broadly this might seem a decent historical point. Peel repealed the Corn Laws which made bread cheaper (and hence allowed employers to lower wages) which was not in the interest of the landowning and farming elements of the Tory Party. It was however in the interests of British capitalism in general as the country became increasingly industrialised. To suppose that whatever Ms May thinks she is doing on Brexit is about the best future for capitalism is where Rees-Mogg’s point fall down. His line however is that in failing to pursue a hard Brexit May is facilitating a split in the Tory Party as Peel did.

His second historical intervention related to the Treaty of Goulet in 1200. While 1846, even if it is well over 150 years ago, is still very much within the broad economic and political framework in which, unfortunately, Britain still operates, the beginning the thirteenth century is not.

The Treaty was about King John handing over some English controlled land in France in return for French recognition of him as King of England. It will be remembered that in 1066 the French had successfully invaded and taken control of the English crown, so one might think that King John was not in the best negotiating position.

Rees-Mogg point was that the concessions made to the French were of the same scale as those made by Theresa May’s Chequers plan for Brexit. It is difficult to see this as a serious historical point.

That is perhaps the key thing about Rees-Mogg the history man. It is remarkably difficult to discover what period of history he actually studied at Oxford, although we do know that he spent time laying down the basis of his later Conservative political career.

I was able to track down someone who had been a fellow student in one seminar group at Oxford with Rees-Mogg who was studying Anglo-Saxon history pre-1966 but they remarked that the degree course was eclectic.

Most recently he has suggested that Theresa May’s EU deal will make Britain a slave State. The above student tweeted on 14th November that since they had studied slavery with him at Oxford he must know this is BS (notwithstanding one’s views on May’s deal).

Jacob Rees-Mogg does know some history but don’t confuse that point with his political pronouncements.

Update #1

Rees Mogg in an interview for the Xmas 2018 edition of the BBC History Magazine has said that his favourite historical figure is nineteenth century Tory Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli. DIsraeli was responsible at Governmental level for the 1867 Reform Act which extended the franchise. He was also responsible for a number of other rather less progressive things and I will post on that later in December

Rees Mogg says:

My history hero: Jacob Rees-Mogg chooses Benjamin Disraeli

“Benjamin Disraeli was a flamboyant, enormously engaging romantic with a way with words, who was also very good at the showmanship side of politics”: Jacob Rees-Mogg, Conservative MP, chooses a 19th-century prime minister

 Update #2

In a further puzzling historical reference Rees-Mogg suggested that while Theresa May had won the confidence vote of Tory MPs on 12th December she should anyway offer her resignation as Prime Minister in accord with constitutional conventions. One wonders which he had in mind. Britain does not have a fully written Constitution but a number of established processes and laws based on the fact that it remains a Constitutional Monarchy rather than a Parliamentary Democracy as such.

The Queen or her representative has the power to dismiss the Prime Minister, as happened with Gough Whitlam in Australia in 1975. In the UK the most recent addition in the area of Elections was the Parliament Act passed in the Cameron/Clegg era which makes it difficult but not impossible to hold a General Election before the full 5 year term has elapsed. Perhaps Rees-Mogg thinks May should go to Parliament and ask for a dissolution. It would be a good idea but I’m not sure, after the last time she did it, that it will happen again

 Update #3

Jacob Rees Mogg’s latest outing as a history man came on the BBC QT programme on 14th February. Defending Churchill after John McDonnell’s comments about TonyPandy, Rees Mogg opined on the Boer War (1899-1902) in which Young Winston fought. Neither the British or the Boers were progressive but in an imperial battle Britain had the upper hand. In gaining it the British interned thousands of Boers in concentration camps in poor conditions. Thousands died which under Kitchener was one lever the British used to defeat the Boers. As Rees Mogg pointed out the camps were not the same as the Nazis death camps, but what he didn’t manage to point out was that the underlying principle- not the practice- was the same. He also opined that the actual mortality rate in the camps was the same as Glasgow at the time and that one had to understand the history of the Boer War rather than look at matters from the perspective of 2019. No doubt but from whichever standpoint one takes there is no question that the British pioneered the use of internment and camps. Whether Rees Mogg has studied the period is a moot point (see above)

 

Articles

Brewdog Dalston: open at last

In Uncategorized on April 1, 2019 by kmflett

Brewdog have been suggesting they’d open a bar in Dalston for several years & last Friday they did. Its in the former Birthdays at 33-35 Stoke Newington Rd and handly placed next to a Co-Op should you require any shopping while there. The Co-Op sign is noticeably more blue than the Brewdog but that is a detail.

Brewdog  Dalston has 25 taps and a good number are given over to local beers such as Pressure Drop, Five Points, Hammerton and Howling Hops but not obviously, ahem, Beavertown.

I tried a ‘live’ Black Hammer BIPA which was decent at 7.2%. On a Monday night there was ample seating on the ground floor (there is also a lower ground) and the barperson addressed me as ‘sir’. This suggests that opposition to the licence from those who claimed it would attract thrill seekers was wide of the mark. As a trade union officer I dont do thrill seeking anyway.

If you want the benchmark (come all you KPI fans out there) Punk is £5.80 a pint. Its £5 a pint in Brewdog Cardiff and £3.79 in most Wetherspoons. My views on market capitalism can be found elsewhere

I’m not an unequivocal fan of Brewdog but there is certainly room for this and probably more of their bars in north-east London. If you want a bit more (but not entirely) independent Red Hand (unmarked bar, show beard for entry) is immediately opposite. More subdued lighting, more relaxing and the toilets are on the level (look I’m 62 you know).

Articles

April Fool’s Day; Turning the World Upside Down, but only for a day

In Uncategorized on March 31, 2019 by kmflett

April Fool’s Day: Turning the World Upside Down, but only for a day

April Fool’s Day is not an ancient tradition. Ronald Hutton in his definitive Stations of the Sun notes it first appeared in Britain around 1680 from continental Europe and became common only in the nineteenth century.

It also had a limited element of misrule, taking the rise out of the rich and powerful, but in a much more restricted timespan than the earlier post-Christmas period of the Lords of Misrule.

The celebration of Misrule which in earlier times extended from Boxing Day to Twelfth Night now took place just on April 1st.

Given the current period of Misrule in Britain the timing of a day to promote it in a mildly subversive way works rather well.

Full marks to the inhabitants of Middleton in Lancashire who used the day to elect a mock-Mayor from the town’s drunks, cover him in soot and grease, and paraded him around town on a pole soliciting money (for drink).

Misrule can be subversive and fun as well.

Articles

Gareth Southgate faces cricketer David Warner for Beard of Spring 2019

In Uncategorized on March 31, 2019 by kmflett

 Beard Liberation Front

31st March

Contact Keith Flett 07803 167266

Gareth Southgate faces cricketer David Warner for Beard of Spring 2019

The Beard Liberation Front, the informal network of beard wearers, has said that voting is now open for the coveted Beard of Spring Award.

Beard of Spring is the second of four seasonal awards that lead to the Beard of the Year in December.

The campaigners say that while the second seasonal award of the year traditionally focuses on new beard growth with Easter so late, the focus is more on those whose beards have appeared in a positive public light during the quarter.

England football manager Gareth Southgate, a nearly man in earlier beard awards, has enhanced the public image of the hirsute while disgraced Australian cricketer David Warner has returned to IPL cricket with a more positive hirsute intent.

BLF Organiser Keith Flett said, the short list for Beard of Spring has a majority who have never appeared before so it will be interesting to see how the public vote goes

The vote is open now and will close at midday on Good Friday, with the winner announced on Easter Saturday

Beard of Spring 2019

Gareth Southgate, England football manager

Rick Wakeman, musician

Alexei Sayle, comedian

Logan Plant, brewer

Raheem Sterling, footballer

Scott Wagstaff, footballer

David Warner, cricketer

Dotun Adebayo, broadcaster

Garrett Oliver, brewer

Ian Jack, journalist

Articles

Ambridge Socialist poll: Performance Management in Ambridge. Will Grundy’s cider barn be impacted?

In Uncategorized on March 31, 2019 by kmflett

Ambridge Socialist poll

The Grundy’s cider barn is one of the great institutions of Ambridge life. It is traditional in format although recently modernised to add a portable toilet.

Performance Management is sweeping Ambridge. Adam is micro-managing Ed’s seed drilling, while Alastair’s new employers are keen to see him meet targets for selling things to his veterinary client based that they dont want.

Will the Grundy’s cider barn succumb? Will Joe Grundy be required to produce key performance indicators relating to how much cider has been sold each week and whether the portaloo was working properly? Or will the Grundy’s hold out against the advance of neo-liberalism?

 

Articles

Ambridge Socialist: Ambridge debt crisis

In Uncategorized on March 31, 2019 by kmflett

The Ambridge Socialist

All the news of the class struggle in Borsetshire

March 31st

Crisis as Natasha’s credit card debt is revealed

While looking for Natasha’s misplaced tax return Tom has discovered her credit card statement which reveals a debt of £8,000. This seems a like a huge amount to small scale businessman Tom. After deciding to play Sherlock Holmes Tom discovered further cards and further debits. He promptly pulled out of the house they had planned to live in, in Penny Hassett.

What Natasha doesn’t realise is how long she’ll need to appear in the Archers in order to earn enough to pay her debts off

Call Me Russ set to meet Freddie

Forget Brexit, the showdown of April will be when Freddie newly released from jail and super fit after using the prison gym discovers that his former tormenter Call Me Russ is a resident at his ancestral home. Even worse he appears to be getting on well with his mother….

Performance Management

Adam is trying to micro-manage Ed. Meanwhile Alastair has been set targets and performance plans by his new veterinary employers. Its difficult to see neo-liberalism reaching the Grundy’s cider barn though.

In other news

Leonard is painting Shula’s portrait or possibly a horse (apparently much the same thing)

Pip and Toby are going ahead with the christening of Rosie. Or are they. They need a lecture from Jim on religion