Eric Hobsbawm as an historian revisited.

Richard J Evans biography of Eric Hobsbawm is due to be published on 7th February and looks to be well worth reading.
A summary written by Evans is here:
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/jan/17/eric-hobsbawm-mi5-communism-stalin-historian-private-papers
Evans makes the point that while Hobsbawm used the ideas and concepts of Marxism is in historical work he was not confined by them. This gave him the ability to develop new areas of historical research which remain relevant today.
I agree although I think Hobsbawm’s historical strength also lay in his command of historical detail.
Below is a (slightly edited) piece I wrote on this from 2013 and the section of Evans piece that refers specifically to Hobsbawm’s historical writing.
Richard J Evans on Eric Hobsbawm the historian
How did all this affect his practice as a historian? Is there any connection between Hobsbawm’s communism and the global fame and success of his historical writings?
The first and perhaps the most important thing to note is that his historical work was never purely Marxist. Far from being a “central European intellectual”, as some have claimed, he was influenced above all by French intellectual ideas, particularly those of the group of historians associated with the periodical Annales. Hobsbawm’s mentor at Cambridge in the late 1930s and afterwards, the economic historian Mounia Postan, introduced him to the work of the Annales, inviting their leading figure Marc Bloch to Cambridge and sharing in many respects their belief in history as an all-encompassing discipline, dealing analytically not only with politics, economy and society but also with the arts and indeed all aspects of life in the past.
Hobsbawm deepened this acquaintance with the French historical school in the 1950s, when he spent long periods in Paris mixing with dissident leftwing intellectuals. His book, The Age of Revolution, published in 1962, clearly showed the influence of the Annales, as did its successors The Age of Capital and The Age of Empire. What gave his writing a particularly wide appeal was nevertheless its indebtedness to Marxist models of interpretation, deployed with clarity and power and illustrated with examples and evidence taken from an astonishingly wide range of sources in a variety of languages. Here, his deep reading of European literature, beginning in his teenage years, displayed its influence in a style that combined elegance and wit, engaging the reader in a way that no conventional Marxist exposition could ever manage to do.
Marxist ideas helped him to develop concepts that made sense of the inchoate material of history
At the same time, like the other English Marxist historians such as Thompson, Hobsbawm was intellectually liberated by his distancing from the British Communist party in 1956. From writing in the 1940s and early 1950s about the rise of the working class, he turned to studying marginal and deviant people in history, “primitive rebels”, millenarians, Luddites, bandits, seemingly irrational popular movements that in fact expressed a strong degree of rationality in their rebellion against the encroachments of capitalism on their way of life. Of course, he slotted them into a basically Marxist teleology (they were “primitive” rebels after all, unlike the supposedly sophisticated modern rebels of Marxist labour movements). Still, the sympathy with which he treated them was obvious to everyone who was able to read between the lines.
Marxist ideas gave his work a coherence and structure that merely empirical history was unable to achieve; they helped him to develop concepts that made sense of the inchoate material of history, and at the same time, because they were novel and controversial, provided topics for debates and discussions that are still going on among historians today – “the general crisis of the 17th century”, “the declining standard of living in the industrial revolution”, “social banditry”, “the invention of tradition”, “the long 19th century” and many more. At the same time, concepts and ideas never forced the basic evidence on to the sidelines. Where fact and interpretation clashed, Hobsbawm was almost always scrupulous enough to yield to fact, as, for example, in his abandonment of Marxist theories of imperialism in his book The Age of Empire. Neither as a communist intellectual nor as a practising historian was he ever a mere propagandist.
My assessment (2013): Hobsbawm & detail
According to Wikipedia [so it must be true] I wrote my first letter to the Guardian on Eric Hobsbawm and Soviet history several aeons ago now. On Saturday 30th March 2013 I had a further letter published on Hobsbawm [Ive had a few letters published inbetween on other matters]which was probably rather kinder to the late historian than I had been in 1986.
Different times and contexts apply and as Hobsbawm died in 2012 and the last book he worked on while he was still alive, a collection of mostly previously unpublished essays, Fractured Times, has was published in 2013. It is more a question now of defending what was good about Hobsbawm’s work and carrying on the tradition.
Richard Evans reviewing the book in The Guardian [23rd March 2013] argues that the key thing about Hobsbawm was the range and sweep of his historical knowledge, his belief in the grand historical narrative.
That is a belief that I share and there is no question that Hobsbawm’s grasp of what is now called the big picture also facilitated his unparalleled grasp of historical detail, but while detail can be researched, grand narratives are in part conjecture.
Hobsbawm was at his least reliable, although always thought and argument provoking, when working with a big canvass. So, for example his essay on the ‘forward march of labour halted’ ,certainly viewed with hindsight, made some perceptive points about changes in the UK labour movement in the late 1970s. The political front end which Hobsbawm’s co-thinkers in Marxism Today put on the essay which underwrote theoretically the New Labour project seemed to me both at the time and now substantially wrong.
My letter in the Guardian argued that the Hobsbawm that is really worth pursuing now is the historian whose insights and research gave us groundbreaking works such as Primitive Rebels and [with George Rude] Captain Swing.
Sampling the essays in Fractured Times one gets a feel for the historical approach that Hobsbawm made his own.
There are several paragraphs in different essays on the role of the horse in the development of capitalism. It is an unusual insight and all the more interesting for that. Hobsbawm also returns to a subject he has mentioned before, Australian sheep shearers. An itinerant workforce they were also strong union men. Hobsbawm notes that they had sympathy for the 1917 Russian Revolution enough indeed to attend a solidarity meeting. However when police searched some attendees for subversive literature they found only multiple copies of a leaflet noting that if water rotted the boots of sheepshearers think what it might do so their stomachs.
Hobsbawm identifies the historical moment when the spaghetti western film appeared, why and the impact it had on Clint Eastwood’s career and notes of the trend towards identity politics that it would have struggled with: ‘the old English socialist militant who claimed on his deathbed that he believed in Jesus Christ, Keir Hardie and Huddersfield United’.
In short for all the power of his grand narratives when it comes to the real strength of Eric Hobsbawm as an historian the devil really was in the detail.